Quillivan Rebecca R, Burlison Jonathan D, Browne Emily K, Scott Susan D, Hoffman James M
Quality and Safety, St. Jude Children's Research Hospital, Memphis, USA.
Jt Comm J Qual Patient Saf. 2016 Aug;42(8):377-86. doi: 10.1016/s1553-7250(16)42053-2.
Second victim experiences can affect the wellbeing of health care providers and compromise patient safety. Many factors associated with improved coping after patient safety event involvement are also components of a strong patient safety culture, so that supportive patient safety cultures may reduce second victim-related trauma. A cross-sectional survey study was conducted to assess the influence of patient safety culture on second victim-related distress.
The Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ) Hospital Survey on Patient Safety Culture (HSOPSC) and the Second Victim Experience and Support Tool (SVEST), which was developed to assess organizational support and personal and professional distress after involvement in a patient safety event, were administered to nurses involved in direct patient care.
Of 358 nurses at a specialized pediatric hospital, 169 (47.2%) completed both surveys. Hierarchical linear regres sion demonstrated that the patient safety culture survey dimension nonpunitive response to error was significantly associated with reductions in the second victim survey dimensions psychological, physical, and professional distress (p < 0.001). As a mediator, organizational support fully explained the nonpunitive response to error-physical distress and nonpunitive response to error-professional distress relationships and partially explained the nonpunitive response to error-psychological distress relationship.
The results suggest that punitive safety cultures may contribute to self-reported perceptions of second victim-related psychological, physical, and professional distress, which could reflect a lack of organizational support. Reducing punitive response to error and encouraging supportive coworker, supervisor, and institutional interactions may be useful strategies to manage the severity of second victim experiences.
“二次受害者”经历会影响医护人员的身心健康,并危及患者安全。许多与参与患者安全事件后更好应对相关的因素也是强大的患者安全文化的组成部分,因此支持性的患者安全文化可能会减少与“二次受害者”相关的创伤。开展了一项横断面调查研究,以评估患者安全文化对与“二次受害者”相关困扰的影响。
向直接参与患者护理的护士发放了医疗保健研究与质量局(AHRQ)的《医院患者安全文化调查》(HSOPSC)以及为评估参与患者安全事件后的组织支持以及个人和职业困扰而开发的《二次受害者经历与支持工具》(SVEST)。
在一家专科儿童医院的358名护士中,169名(47.2%)完成了两项调查。分层线性回归表明,患者安全文化调查维度“对差错的非惩罚性反应”与“二次受害者”调查维度中心理、身体和职业困扰的减少显著相关(p < 0.001)。作为一个中介变量,组织支持完全解释了“对差错的非惩罚性反应 - 身体困扰”和“对差错的非惩罚性反应 - 职业困扰”之间的关系,并部分解释了“对差错的非惩罚性反应 - 心理困扰”之间的关系。
结果表明,惩罚性的安全文化可能会导致自我报告的与“二次受害者”相关的心理、身体和职业困扰感,这可能反映出缺乏组织支持。减少对差错的惩罚性反应并鼓励同事、上级和机构之间的支持性互动,可能是管理“二次受害者”经历严重程度的有用策略。