Iniguez Kristen C, Stankowski Rachel V
Child Advocacy Center and Department of Pediatrics, Marshfield Clinic, Marshfield, Wisconsin, USA
Marshfield Clinic Research Foundation, Marshfield, Wisconsin, USA.
Clin Med Res. 2016 Dec;14(3-4):126-137. doi: 10.3121/cmr.2016.1306. Epub 2016 Aug 8.
Adverse childhood experiences (ACEs), including emotional abuse, substance abuse in the household, separation or divorce, physical abuse, violence between adults, mental illness in the household, sexual abuse, or incarceration of a household member, have the potential to profoundly impact health and well-being in adulthood. To assess whether previously reported relationships between ACEs and health outcomes withstand validation, we conducted a community-based ACE study with the unique capacity to link self-reported ACEs and other survey results to validated health data in an electronic medical record (EMR).
Information regarding ACEs and health outcomes was captured from 2013-2014 via a telephone survey of residents of the predominantly rural northern and central regions of Wisconsin and electronic abstraction of EMR data. ACE score was calculated by counting each exposure as one point. We examined the relationship between ACE score, type, and self-reported and validated health outcomes.
A total of 800 participants completed the telephone survey. Overall, 62% reported at least one ACE and 15% reported experiencing four or more. All self-reported measures of poor health were associated with increased ACE score. EMR data were positively correlated with ACE score for increased body mass index and diagnoses of depression, anxiety, and asthma. In contrast, diagnoses of hypertension, hypercholesterolemia, myocardial infarction, and skin and other cancers were inversely related to ACE score. Emotional abuse was the most common ACE reported followed by substance abuse in the household. ACEs tended to cluster so that people who reported at least one ACE were likely to have experienced multiple ACEs. There was no clear correlation between abuse type (e.g., direct abuse vs. household dysfunction) and health outcomes.
In the first community-based study to link self-reported ACEs to comprehensive health measures documented in the medical record, we observed previously reported associations between childhood adversity and poor outcomes in adulthood, but also noted an inverse relationship between ACE score and certain medical diagnoses. Potential explanations for this finding warrant further investigation.
童年不良经历(ACEs),包括情感虐待、家庭中的物质滥用、分居或离婚、身体虐待、成人之间的暴力、家庭中的精神疾病、性虐待或家庭成员被监禁,有可能对成年后的健康和幸福产生深远影响。为了评估先前报道的ACEs与健康结果之间的关系是否经得起验证,我们开展了一项基于社区的ACE研究,该研究具有将自我报告的ACEs和其他调查结果与电子病历(EMR)中的验证健康数据相联系的独特能力。
2013年至2014年期间,通过对威斯康星州北部和中部主要农村地区居民的电话调查以及EMR数据的电子提取,获取了有关ACEs和健康结果的信息。ACE分数通过将每次暴露计为一分来计算。我们研究了ACE分数、类型与自我报告及验证后的健康结果之间的关系。
共有800名参与者完成了电话调查。总体而言,62%的人报告至少有一次ACE经历,15%的人报告经历过四次或更多次。所有自我报告的健康状况不佳指标都与ACE分数增加有关。EMR数据与ACE分数呈正相关,表现为体重指数增加以及抑郁症、焦虑症和哮喘诊断。相比之下,高血压、高胆固醇血症、心肌梗死以及皮肤癌和其他癌症的诊断与ACE分数呈负相关。情感虐待是报告最多的ACE类型,其次是家庭中的物质滥用。ACEs往往会聚集在一起,因此报告至少一次ACE经历的人可能经历过多次ACEs。虐待类型(例如,直接虐待与家庭功能障碍)与健康结果之间没有明显的相关性
在第一项将自我报告的ACEs与病历中记录的综合健康指标相联系的基于社区的研究中,我们观察到了先前报道的童年逆境与成年不良后果之间的关联,但也注意到ACE分数与某些医学诊断之间存在负相关。这一发现的潜在解释值得进一步研究。