Bryceland James K, Drury Colin, Tait Gavin R
Department of Orthopaedics, University Hospital Crosshouse, Kilmarnock KA2 0BE, UK.
Shoulder Elbow. 2015 Jul;7(3):164-7. doi: 10.1177/1758573215571010. Epub 2015 Jan 30.
Controversy presently exists surrounding the management of patients with subacromial impingement. This study aims to highlight current UK practices in the management of these patients.
BESS members were invited to complete a questionnaire and responses were received from 157 consultant shoulder surgeons.
Physiotherapy is an integral part of management for 93% of surgeons with a minimum period of 12 weeks being most popular prior to consideration of arthroscopic subacromial decompression. Subacromial steroid injection is used by 95% and 86% repeat this if the patient has failed to respond to a previous injection by the general practioner. From initial presentation, 77% felt there should be at least 3 months of conservative management before proceeding to surgery. Good but transient response to subacromial injection was considered the best predictor of good surgical outcome by 77%. The coracoacromial ligament is fully released by 78%, although there was greater variation in how aggressive surgeons were with acromioplasty. Most (59%) do not include the nontender acromioclavicular joint to any extent in routine acromioplasty. Hospital physiotherapy protocols are used by 63% for postoperative rehabilitation.
Variation exists in the management regimes offered to patients with subacromial impingement, but most employ a minimum period of 12 weeks of conservative management incorporating physiotherapy and at least 2 subacromial steriod injections.
目前,关于肩峰下撞击症患者的治疗存在争议。本研究旨在突出英国目前对这些患者的治疗方法。
邀请英国肩肘外科协会(BESS)成员填写一份问卷,共收到157位肩关节外科顾问医生的回复。
93%的外科医生将物理治疗作为治疗的一个组成部分,在考虑关节镜下肩峰下减压之前,最常用的物理治疗最短疗程为12周。95%的医生会使用肩峰下类固醇注射,如果患者对全科医生之前的注射没有反应,86%的医生会重复注射。从初次就诊开始,77%的医生认为在进行手术前至少应有3个月的保守治疗。77%的医生认为肩峰下注射后有良好但短暂的反应是手术良好结果的最佳预测指标。78%的医生会完全松解喙肩韧带,不过在肩峰成形术的激进程度上,医生之间存在较大差异。大多数医生(59%)在常规肩峰成形术中在任何程度上都不包括无压痛的肩锁关节。63%的医生在术后康复中使用医院的物理治疗方案。
对于肩峰下撞击症患者的治疗方案存在差异,但大多数方案采用至少12周的保守治疗,包括物理治疗和至少2次肩峰下类固醇注射。