O'Neil Mary Lou
Gender and Women's Studies Research Center, Kadir Has University, Kadir Has Caddesi, Cibali, 34083 Istanbul, Turkey.
Contraception. 2017 Feb;95(2):148-153. doi: 10.1016/j.contraception.2016.09.009. Epub 2016 Sep 12.
Abortion in Turkey has been legal since 1983 and remains so today. Despite this, in 2012 the Prime Minister declared that, in his opinion, abortion was murder. Since then, there has been growing evidence that abortion access particularly in state hospitals is being restricted, although no new legislation has been offered.
The study aimed to determine the number of state hospitals in Turkey that provide abortions.
The study employed a telephone survey in 2015-2016 where 431 state hospitals were contacted and asked a set of questions by a mystery patient. If possible, information was obtained directly from the obstetrics/gynecology department. I removed specialist hospitals from the data set and the remaining data were analyzed for frequency and cross-tabulations were performed.
Only 7.8% of state hospitals provide abortion services without regard to reason which is provided for by the current law, while 78% provide abortions when there is a medical necessity. Of the 58 teaching and research hospitals in Turkey, 9 (15.5%) provide abortion care without restriction to reason, 38 (65.5%) will do the procedure if there is a medical necessity and 11 (11.4%) of these hospitals refuse to provide abortion services under any circumstances. There are two regions, encompassing 1.5 million women of childbearing age, where no state hospital provides for abortion without restriction as to reason.
The vast majority of state hospitals only provide abortions in the narrow context of a medical necessity, and thus are not implementing the law to its full extent. It is clear that although no new legislation restricting abortion has been enacted, state hospitals are reducing the provision of abortion services without restriction as to reason.
This is the only nationwide study to focus on abortion provision at state hospitals.
土耳其自1983年起堕胎合法化,至今仍是如此。尽管如此,2012年总理宣称,在他看来,堕胎就是谋杀。从那时起,越来越多的证据表明,尤其是在公立医院,堕胎服务的获取受到了限制,尽管并没有出台新的立法。
本研究旨在确定土耳其提供堕胎服务的公立医院数量。
该研究在2015年至2016年进行了电话调查,联系了431家公立医院,并由一名神秘患者询问一系列问题。如果可能,直接从妇产科获取信息。我从数据集中剔除了专科医院,对其余数据进行频率分析并制作交叉表。
只有7.8%的公立医院在不考虑现行法律规定的理由的情况下提供堕胎服务,而78%的医院在有医疗必要时提供堕胎服务。在土耳其的58家教学和研究医院中,9家(15.5%)无限制地提供堕胎护理,38家(65.5%)在有医疗必要时会进行堕胎手术,11家(11.4%)的这些医院在任何情况下都拒绝提供堕胎服务。有两个地区,涵盖150万育龄妇女,没有一家公立医院在不考虑理由的情况下提供堕胎服务。
绝大多数公立医院仅在有医疗必要的狭窄范围内提供堕胎服务,因此并未充分执行法律。很明显,尽管没有颁布限制堕胎的新立法,但公立医院正在减少不考虑理由的堕胎服务提供。
这是唯一一项专注于公立医院堕胎服务提供情况的全国性研究。