Scholz Brett, Bocking Julia, Happell Brenda
SYNERGY Nursing and Midwifery Research Centre, University of Canberra and ACT Health, The Canberra Hospital, Garran, ACT 2605, Australia. Email:.
Aust Health Rev. 2017 Oct;41(5):505-510. doi: 10.1071/AH16105.
Objectives Contemporary mental health policies call for consumers to be involved in decision-making processes within mental health organisations. Some organisations have embraced leadership roles for consumers, but research suggests consumers remain disempowered within mental health services. Drawing on a service-dominant logic, which emphasises the co-creation of value of services, the present study provides an overview of consumer leadership within mental health organisations in the Australian Capital Territory. Methods Mental health organisations subscribing to the local peak body mailing list were invited to complete a survey about consumer leadership. Survey data were summarised using descriptive statistics and interpreted through the lens of service-dominant logic. Results Ways in which organisations may create opportunities for consumers to co-create value within their mental health services included soliciting feedback, involving consumer leaders in service design, having consumer leaders involved in hiring decisions and employing consumer leaders as staff or on boards. Strategies that organisations used to develop consumer leaders included induction, workshops and training in a variety of organisational processes and skills. Conclusions The findings of the present study extend the application of a service-dominant logic framework to consumer leadership within mental health organisations through consideration of the diverse opportunities that organisations can provide for consumer co-creation of service offerings. What is known about the topic? Policy calls for consumer involvement in all levels of mental health service planning, implementation and delivery. The extent to which service organisations have included consumer leaders varies, but research suggests that this inclusion can be tokenistic or that organisations choose to work with consumers who are less likely to challenge the status quo. Service literature has explored the way consumers can co-create value of their own health care, but is yet to explore consumers' co-creation of value at a systemic level. What does the paper add? This paper outlines ways in which mental health organisations report involving consumers in leadership positions, including having consumers on boards, having consumers on recruitment panels and providing leadership training for consumers. These initiatives are considered in terms of the potential value co-created within mental health services by consumers in leadership, suggesting that consumer leaders are a resource to mental health organisations in terms of the value brought to service offerings. What are the implications for practitioners? Research suggests that medical professionals have been resistant to increased consumer leadership within mental health services. The findings of the present study emphasise the value that can be brought to service organisations by consumer leaders, suggesting that mental health practitioners may reconsider their approach and attitudes towards consumer leadership in the sector.
目标 当代心理健康政策要求消费者参与心理健康组织的决策过程。一些组织赋予了消费者领导角色,但研究表明,消费者在心理健康服务中仍然缺乏权力。本研究运用强调服务价值共同创造的服务主导逻辑,概述了澳大利亚首都地区心理健康组织中的消费者领导力。方法 邀请订阅当地行业协会邮件列表的心理健康组织完成一项关于消费者领导力的调查。调查数据采用描述性统计进行汇总,并通过服务主导逻辑的视角进行解读。结果 组织为消费者在其心理健康服务中共同创造价值创造机会的方式包括征求反馈、让消费者领袖参与服务设计、让消费者领袖参与招聘决策以及聘请消费者领袖担任员工或加入董事会。组织培养消费者领袖的策略包括入职培训、举办研讨会以及针对各种组织流程和技能进行培训。结论 本研究的结果通过考虑组织可为消费者共同创造服务产品提供的各种机会,将服务主导逻辑框架的应用扩展到了心理健康组织中的消费者领导力。关于该主题已知的情况是什么?政策要求消费者参与心理健康服务规划、实施和提供的各个层面。服务组织纳入消费者领袖的程度各不相同,但研究表明这种纳入可能只是形式上的,或者组织选择与不太可能挑战现状的消费者合作。服务文献探讨了消费者共同创造自身医疗保健价值的方式,但尚未探讨消费者在系统层面共同创造价值的情况。本文补充了什么内容?本文概述了心理健康组织报告的让消费者担任领导职位的方式,包括让消费者加入董事会、让消费者参与招聘小组以及为消费者提供领导力培训。这些举措从消费者担任领导角色在心理健康服务中共同创造的潜在价值方面进行了考量,表明消费者领袖在为服务产品带来价值方面是心理健康组织的一种资源。对从业者有何启示?研究表明,医疗专业人员一直抵制心理健康服务中消费者领导力的增强。本研究的结果强调了消费者领袖可为服务组织带来的价值,表明心理健康从业者可能需要重新考虑他们在该领域对消费者领导力的态度和方法。