Jolly Saira Parveen, Rahman Mahfuzar, Afsana Kaosar, Yunus Fakir Md, Chowdhury Ahmed M R
Research and Evaluation Division, BRAC, Mohakhali, Dhaka 1212, Bangladesh.
Health, Nutrition and Population Program, BRAC, Mohakhali, Dhaka 1212, Bangladesh.
PLoS One. 2016 Oct 12;11(10):e0162825. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0162825. eCollection 2016.
A continuous influx of poor people to urban slums poses a challenge to Bangladesh's health system as it has failed to tackle maternal morbidity and mortality. BRAC is the largest non-governmental organisation in Bangladesh. BRAC has been working to reduce maternal, neonatal and under-five children morbidity and mortality of slum dwellers in cities. BRAC has been doing this work for a decade through a programme called MANOSHI. This programme provides door-to-door services to its beneficiaries through community health workers (CHWs) and normal delivery service through its delivery and maternity centres. BRAC started the 'MANOSHI' programme in Narayanganj City Corporation during 2011 to address maternal, neonatal and child health problems facing slum dwellers. We investigated the existing maternal health-service indicators in the slums of Narayanganj City Corporation and compared the findings with a non-intervention area.
This cross-sectional study was conducted during 2012, in 47 slums of Narayanganj City Corporation as intervention and 10 slums of Narsingdi Sadar Municipality as comparison area. A total of 1206 married women, aged 15-49 years, with a pregnancy outcome in the previous year were included for interview. Data on socio-demographic characteristics, reproductive and maternal health-care practices like use of contraceptive methods, antenatal care (ANC), delivery care, postnatal care (PNC) were collected through a structured questionnaire. The chi-square test, Student t test, Mann Whitney U-test, factor analysis and log-binominal test were performed by using STATA statistical software for analysing data.
The activities of BRAC CHWs significantly improved four or more ANC (47% vs. 21%; p<0.000) and PNC (48% vs. 39%; p<0.01) coverage in the intervention slums compared to comparison slums. Still, about half of the deliveries in both areas were attended at home by unskilled birth attendants, of which a very few received PNC within 48 hours after delivery. The poorest and illiterate women received fewer maternal health services from medically trained providers (MTPs). The poorest had a lower likelihood of receiving services from MTPs during delivery complications.
The MANOSHI programme service coverage for delivery care and PNC-checkup for women who prefer home delivery needs to be improved. For sustainable improvement of maternal health outcomes in urban slums, the programme needs to facilitate access to services for poor and illiterate women.
贫困人口持续涌入城市贫民窟,给孟加拉国的卫生系统带来了挑战,因为该系统未能解决孕产妇发病率和死亡率问题。孟加拉农村发展委员会(BRAC)是孟加拉国最大的非政府组织。BRAC一直致力于降低城市贫民窟居民的孕产妇、新生儿和5岁以下儿童的发病率和死亡率。BRAC通过一个名为“玛诺希”(MANOSHI)的项目开展这项工作已有十年。该项目通过社区卫生工作者(CHW)为受益人提供上门服务,并通过其分娩和产妇护理中心提供正常分娩服务。BRAC于2011年在纳拉扬甘杰市议会启动了“玛诺希”项目,以解决贫民窟居民面临的孕产妇、新生儿和儿童健康问题。我们调查了纳拉扬甘杰市议会贫民窟现有的孕产妇保健服务指标,并将结果与一个非干预地区进行了比较。
这项横断面研究于2012年进行,在纳拉扬甘杰市议会的47个贫民窟作为干预地区,在纳西丁萨达尔市议会的10个贫民窟作为对照地区。共有1206名年龄在15 - 49岁、上一年有妊娠结局的已婚妇女被纳入访谈。通过结构化问卷收集社会人口学特征、生殖和孕产妇保健实践(如避孕方法的使用、产前保健(ANC)、分娩护理、产后保健(PNC))的数据。使用STATA统计软件进行卡方检验、学生t检验、曼 - 惠特尼U检验、因子分析和对数二项检验来分析数据。
与对照贫民窟相比,BRAC社区卫生工作者的活动显著提高了干预贫民窟中四次或更多次产前保健(47%对21%;p<0.000)和产后保健(48%对39%;p<0.01)的覆盖率。尽管如此,两个地区仍有约一半的分娩由无技能的接生员在家中进行,其中很少有人在分娩后48小时内接受产后保健。最贫困和文盲妇女从受过医学培训的提供者(MTP)那里获得的孕产妇保健服务较少。最贫困的妇女在分娩并发症期间从MTP那里获得服务的可能性较低。
对于倾向于在家分娩的妇女,“玛诺希”项目的分娩护理和产后保健检查服务覆盖率需要提高。为了可持续地改善城市贫民窟的孕产妇健康结果,该项目需要为贫困和文盲妇女提供获得服务的便利。