Whitney Daniel G, Singh Harshvardhan, Miller Freeman, Barbe Mary F, Slade Jill M, Pohlig Ryan T, Modlesky Christopher M
Department of Kinesiology and Applied Physiology, University of Delaware, Newark, DE, United States.
Department of Orthopedics, Nemours AI duPont Hospital for Children, Wilmington, DE, United States.
Bone. 2017 Jan;94:90-97. doi: 10.1016/j.bone.2016.10.005. Epub 2016 Oct 11.
Nonambulatory children with severe cerebral palsy (CP) have underdeveloped bone architecture, low bone strength and a high degree of fat infiltration in the lower extremity musculature. The present study aims to determine if such a profile exists in ambulatory children with mild CP and if excess fat infiltration extends into the bone marrow.
Ambulatory children with mild spastic CP and typically developing children (4 to 11years; 12/group) were compared. Magnetic resonance imaging was used to estimate cortical bone, bone marrow and total bone volume and width, bone strength [i.e., section modulus (Z) and polar moment of inertia (J)], and bone marrow fat concentration in the midtibia, and muscle volume, intermuscular, subfascial, and subcutaneous adipose tissue (AT) volume and intramuscular fat concentration in the midleg. Accelerometer-based activity monitors worn on the ankle were used to assess physical activity.
There were no group differences in age, height, body mass, body mass percentile, BMI, BMI percentile or tibia length, but children with CP had lower height percentile (19th vs. 50th percentile) and total physical activity counts (44%) than controls (both p<0.05). Children with CP also had lower cortical bone volume (30%), cortical bone width in the posterior (16%) and medial (32%) portions of the shaft, total bone width in the medial-lateral direction (15%), Z in the medial-lateral direction (34%), J (39%) and muscle volume (39%), and higher bone marrow fat concentration (82.1±1.8% vs. 80.5±1.9%), subfascial AT volume (3.3 fold) and intramuscular fat concentration (25.0±8.0% vs. 16.1±3.3%) than controls (all p<0.05). When tibia length was statistically controlled, all group differences in bone architecture, bone strength, muscle volume and fat infiltration estimates, except posterior cortical bone width, were still present (all p<0.05). Furthermore, a higher intermuscular AT volume in children with CP compared to controls emerged (p<0.05).
Ambulatory children with mild spastic CP exhibit an underdeveloped bone architecture and low bone strength in the midtibia and a greater infiltration of fat in the bone marrow and surrounding musculature compared to typically developing children. Whether the deficit in the musculoskeletal system of children with CP is associated with higher chronic disease risk and whether the deficit can be mitigated requires further investigation.
重度脑瘫(CP)的非行走儿童骨骼结构发育不全,骨强度低,下肢肌肉组织脂肪浸润程度高。本研究旨在确定轻度CP的行走儿童是否存在这种情况,以及过多的脂肪浸润是否会延伸至骨髓。
比较轻度痉挛型CP的行走儿童和正常发育儿童(4至11岁;每组12人)。采用磁共振成像估计胫骨中部的皮质骨、骨髓和总骨体积与宽度、骨强度[即截面模量(Z)和极惯性矩(J)]以及骨髓脂肪浓度,以及小腿中部的肌肉体积、肌间、筋膜下和皮下脂肪组织(AT)体积和肌内脂肪浓度。使用佩戴在脚踝上的基于加速度计的活动监测器评估身体活动。
两组在年龄、身高、体重、体重百分位数、BMI、BMI百分位数或胫骨长度方面无差异,但CP儿童的身高百分位数(第19百分位数对第50百分位数)和总身体活动计数(低44%)低于对照组(均p<0.05)。CP儿童的皮质骨体积(低30%)、骨干后部(低16%)和内侧(低32%)的皮质骨宽度、内外侧方向的总骨宽度(低15%)、内外侧方向的Z值(低34%)、J值(低39%)和肌肉体积(低39%)也低于对照组,且骨髓脂肪浓度(82.1±1.8%对80.5±1.9%)、筋膜下AT体积(高3.3倍)和肌内脂肪浓度(25.0±8.0%对16.1±3.3%)高于对照组(均p<0.05)。当对胫骨长度进行统计学控制后,除后部皮质骨宽度外,两组在骨结构、骨强度、肌肉体积和脂肪浸润估计方面的所有差异仍然存在(均p<0.05)。此外,与对照组相比,CP儿童的肌间AT体积更高(p<0.05)。
与正常发育儿童相比,轻度痉挛型CP的行走儿童胫骨中部骨骼结构发育不全,骨强度低,骨髓和周围肌肉组织的脂肪浸润更严重。CP儿童肌肉骨骼系统的缺陷是否与更高的慢性病风险相关,以及该缺陷是否可以减轻,需要进一步研究。