Russell Kelly, Hutchison Michael G, Selci Erin, Leiter Jeff, Chateau Daniel, Ellis Michael J
Department of Pediatrics and Child Health, University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, Canada.
Children's Hospital Research Institute of Manitoba, Winnipeg, Canada.
PLoS One. 2016 Oct 20;11(10):e0165116. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0165116. eCollection 2016.
Many concussion symptoms, such as headaches, vision problems, or difficulty remembering or concentrating may deleteriously affect school functioning. Our objective was to determine if academic performance was lower in the academic calendar year that students sustain a concussion compared to the previous year when they did not sustain a concussion.
Using Manitoba Health and Manitoba Education data, we conducted a population-based, controlled before-after study from 2005-2006 to 2010-2011 academic years. Grade 9-12 students with an ICD9/10 code for concussion were matched to non-concussed controls. Overall changes in grade point average (GPA) were compared for the academic year prior to the concussion to the academic year the concussion occurred (or could have occurred among non-concussed matched students).
Overall, 8240 students (1709 concussed, 6531 non-concussed students) were included. Both concussed and non-concussed students exhibited a lower overall GPA from one year to the next. Having sustained a concussion resulted in a -0.90% (95% CI: -1.88, 0.08) reduction in GPA. Over the same period, non-concussed matched students' GPA reduced by -0.57% (95% CI: -1.32, 0.19). Students who sustained a concussion during high school were just as likely to graduate within four years as their non-concussed peers (ORadj: 0.84; 95% CI: 0.73, 1.02).
We found that, at a population level, a concussion had minimal long-term effects on academic performance during high school. While academic accommodations and Return-to-Learn programs are an important component of pediatric concussion management, research is needed to identify risk factors for poor academic performance after a concussion and who should receive these programs.
许多脑震荡症状,如头痛、视力问题、记忆或注意力集中困难等,可能会对学业产生有害影响。我们的目标是确定与未发生脑震荡的上一年相比,学生在发生脑震荡的学年里学业成绩是否更低。
利用曼尼托巴省卫生部门和曼尼托巴省教育部门的数据,我们在2005 - 2006学年至2010 - 2011学年进行了一项基于人群的前后对照研究。将有国际疾病分类第九版/第十版脑震荡编码的9至12年级学生与未发生脑震荡的对照组进行匹配。比较脑震荡发生前一学年与脑震荡发生学年(或未发生脑震荡的匹配学生可能发生脑震荡的学年)的平均绩点(GPA)总体变化。
总体而言,共纳入8240名学生(1709名发生脑震荡的学生,6531名未发生脑震荡的学生)。发生脑震荡和未发生脑震荡的学生从一年到下一年的总体GPA均有所下降。发生脑震荡导致GPA下降了0.90%(置信区间95%:-1.88,0.08)。在同一时期,未发生脑震荡的匹配学生的GPA下降了0.57%(置信区间95%:-1.32,0.19)。在高中期间发生脑震荡的学生与未发生脑震荡的同龄人四年内毕业的可能性相同(校正比值比:0.84;置信区间95%:0.73,1.02)。
我们发现,在人群层面,脑震荡对高中期间的学业成绩长期影响极小。虽然学业调整和重返学习计划是儿童脑震荡管理的重要组成部分,但仍需要开展研究以确定脑震荡后学业成绩不佳的风险因素以及哪些人应该接受这些计划。