Mars Maurice, Scott Richard E
Dept of TeleHealth, University of KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa.
Stud Health Technol Inform. 2016;231:82-90.
Several spontaneous telemedicine services using WhatsApp Messenger have started in South Africa raising issues of confidentiality, data security and storage, record keeping and reporting. This study reviewed the literature on WhatsApp in clinical practice, to determine how it is used, and users' satisfaction.
Pubmed, Scopus, Science Direct and IEE Expert databases were searched using the search term WhatsApp and Google Scholar using the terms WhatsApp Telemedicine and WhatsApp mHealth.
Thirty-two papers covering 17 disciplines were relevant with the most papers, 12, from India. Seventeen papers reported the use of WhatsApp Groups within departments, 14 of which were surgery related disciplines. Groups improved communication and advice given on patient management. Confidentiality was mentioned in 19 papers and consent in five. Data security was partially addressed in 11 papers with little understanding of how data are transmitted and stored. Telemedicine services outside of departmental groups were reported in seven papers and covered emergency triage in maxillofacial, plastic, neuro and general surgery, and cardiology and telestroke.
WhatsApp is seen to be a simple, cheap and effective means of communication within the clinical health sector and its use will grow. Users have paid little attention to confidentiality, consent and data security. Guidelines for using WhatsApp for telemedicine are required including downloading. WhatsApp messages to computer for integration with electronic medical records.
南非已经启动了几项使用WhatsApp Messenger的自发远程医疗服务,引发了有关保密性、数据安全与存储、记录保存及报告等问题。本研究回顾了临床实践中关于WhatsApp的文献,以确定其使用方式及用户满意度。
使用搜索词WhatsApp在Pubmed、Scopus、Science Direct和IEE Expert数据库中进行检索,并在谷歌学术中使用术语WhatsApp远程医疗和WhatsApp移动健康进行检索。
32篇涵盖17个学科的论文具有相关性,其中数量最多的12篇来自印度。17篇论文报告了在各科室内部使用WhatsApp群组的情况,其中14篇与外科相关学科有关。群组改善了沟通以及关于患者管理的建议。19篇论文提到了保密性,5篇提到了同意。11篇论文部分涉及了数据安全问题,但对数据的传输和存储方式了解甚少。7篇论文报告了科室群组之外的远程医疗服务,涵盖颌面外科、整形外科、神经外科、普通外科、心脏病学和远程中风的紧急分诊。
WhatsApp被视为临床医疗领域一种简单、廉价且有效的沟通方式,其使用将会增加。用户对保密性、同意和数据安全关注甚少。需要制定使用WhatsApp进行远程医疗的指南,包括将WhatsApp消息下载到计算机以便与电子病历整合。