Sbayeh Amgad, Qaedi Choo Mohammad A, Quane Kathleen A, Finucane Paul, McGrath Deirdre, O'Flynn Siun, O'Mahony Siobhain M, O'Tuathaigh Colm M P
Department of Anatomy and Neuroscience, School of Medicine, University College Cork, Cork, Ireland.
Medical Education Unit, School of Medicine, University College Cork, Cork, Ireland.
Perspect Med Educ. 2016 Dec;5(6):338-346. doi: 10.1007/s40037-016-0310-4.
Against a backdrop of ever-changing diagnostic and treatment modalities, stakeholder perceptions (medical students, clinicians, anatomy educators) are crucial for the design of an anatomy curriculum which fulfils the criteria required for safe medical practice. This study compared perceptions of students, practising clinicians, and anatomy educators with respect to the relevance of anatomy education to medicine.
A quantitative survey was administered to undergraduate entry (n = 352) and graduate entry students (n = 219) at two Irish medical schools, recently graduated Irish clinicians (n = 146), and anatomy educators based in Irish and British medical schools (n = 30). Areas addressed included the association of anatomy with medical education and clinical practice, mode of instruction, and curriculum duration.
Graduate-entry students were less likely to associate anatomy with the development of professionalism, teamwork skills, or improved awareness of ethics in medicine. Clinicians highlighted the challenge of tailoring anatomy education to increase student readiness to function effectively in a clinical role. Anatomy educators indicated dissatisfaction with the time available for anatomy within medical curricula, and were equivocal about whether curriculum content should be responsive to societal feedback.
The group differences identified in the current study highlight areas and requirements which medical education curriculum developers should be sensitive to when designing anatomy courses.
在诊断和治疗方式不断变化的背景下,利益相关者(医学生、临床医生、解剖学教育工作者)的看法对于设计符合安全医疗实践所需标准的解剖学课程至关重要。本研究比较了学生、执业临床医生和解剖学教育工作者对解剖学教育与医学相关性的看法。
对爱尔兰两所医学院的本科入学学生(n = 352)和研究生入学学生(n = 219)、近期毕业的爱尔兰临床医生(n = 146)以及爱尔兰和英国医学院的解剖学教育工作者(n = 30)进行了定量调查。涉及的领域包括解剖学与医学教育及临床实践的关联、教学模式和课程时长。
研究生入学学生不太可能将解剖学与专业素养的培养、团队合作技能或医学伦理意识的提高联系起来。临床医生强调了调整解剖学教育以提高学生在临床角色中有效发挥作用的准备程度所面临的挑战。解剖学教育工作者表示对医学课程中解剖学的可用时间不满意,并且对于课程内容是否应响应社会反馈态度模糊。
本研究中确定的群体差异突出了医学教育课程开发者在设计解剖学课程时应敏感对待的领域和要求。