Stricker Paul A, Muhly Wallis T, Jantzen Ellen C, Li Yue, Jawad Abbas F, Long Alexander S, Polansky Marcia, Cook-Sather Scott D
From the Departments of *Anesthesiology and Critical Care Medicine, †Pediatrics, The Children's Hospital of Philadelphia, Perelman School of Medicine at the University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania; and ‡Department of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, Dornsife School of Public Health, Drexel University, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.
Anesth Analg. 2017 Jan;124(1):245-253. doi: 10.1213/ANE.0000000000001722.
Bilateral myringotomy and pressure equalization tube insertion (BMT) is the most common surgery in children. Multiple anesthetic techniques for BMT have been proposed, but that which reliably promotes ideal recovery remains unclear. We sought to assess associations between anesthetic regimens that included single-agent (fentanyl or ketorolac) or dual-agent (fentanyl and ketorolac) analgesic therapy and the primary outcome of maximal postanesthesia care unit (PACU) pain score. Secondary outcomes included in-hospital rescue analgesic administration, recovery time, and emesis incidence.
Principal analysis was conducted on a retrospective cohort of 3669 children aged 6 months to <7 years who underwent BMT over a 16-month period and received intraoperative fentanyl and/or ketorolac. Routine anesthetic care included preoperative oral midazolam, general anesthesia via a mask maintained with sevoflurane and N2O or air in O2, and intramuscular analgesic administration. Multivariable analyses were performed examining relationships between analgesic regimen with the following outcomes: maximum PACU Face, Legs, Activity, Cry, and Consolability (FLACC) score = 0 or 7 to 10, oxycodone administration, and time to discharge readiness. Demographic variables, midazolam exposure, and location (main hospital vs ambulatory surgery center) were included in the multivariable analyses as potential confounders. Associations with postoperative vomiting were studied separately in 2725 children from a subsequent, nonoverlapping 12-month period using similar inclusion criteria. Fentanyl and ketorolac dose-response relationships were evaluated for selected outcome variables.
Maximum FLACC = 0, maximum FLACC score of 7 to 10, and oxycodone rescue were most strongly associated with dual-agent therapy versus single-agent ketorolac: odds ratios 4.89 (95% confidence interval [CI], 4.04-5.93), 0.13 (95% CI, 0.10-0.16), and 0.11 (98.3% CI, 0.09-0.14), respectively, P < .001 for each). Minor associations were found for age, Hispanic ethnicity, midazolam, and location, and none for sex or race. For subjects managed with higher dose fentanyl (≥1.5 µg/kg) and ketorolac (≥0.75 mg/kg), 90% had no demonstrable pain, agitation, or distress. Mean discharge readiness times were 21 ± 11 minutes (ketorolac), 26 ± 16 minutes (fentanyl), and 24 ± 14 minutes (dual) (P < .0001). Postoperative emesis incidences associated with ketorolac (2.7%) versus dual therapy (4.5%) were not different (P = .08).
In this large retrospective pediatric BMT study, combination intramuscular fentanyl/ketorolac was strongly associated with superior PACU analgesia and reduced need for oxycodone rescue without clinically significant increases in recovery time or emesis incidence. Combination fentanyl at 1.5 to 2 µg/kg and 1 mg/kg ketorolac was associated with optimal outcomes. Dual therapy appears similarly effective in children of either European Caucasian or African ancestry or of Hispanic ethnicity.
双侧鼓膜切开置管术(BMT)是儿童中最常见的手术。已经提出了多种用于BMT的麻醉技术,但哪种技术能可靠地促进理想恢复尚不清楚。我们试图评估包含单药(芬太尼或酮咯酸)或双药(芬太尼和酮咯酸)镇痛治疗的麻醉方案与麻醉后监护病房(PACU)最大疼痛评分这一主要结局之间的关联。次要结局包括住院期间的补救性镇痛药物使用、恢复时间和呕吐发生率。
对3669名年龄在6个月至<7岁之间、在16个月期间接受BMT并术中使用芬太尼和/或酮咯酸的儿童进行回顾性队列的主要分析。常规麻醉护理包括术前口服咪达唑仑、通过面罩以七氟醚和N2O或氧气中的空气维持的全身麻醉以及肌肉注射镇痛药物。进行多变量分析以检查镇痛方案与以下结局之间的关系:PACU面部、腿部、活动、哭闹和安慰性(FLACC)最大评分=0或7至10、使用羟考酮、以及准备出院时间。人口统计学变量、咪达唑仑使用情况和地点(主医院与门诊手术中心)作为潜在混杂因素纳入多变量分析。使用相似纳入标准,对随后一个不重叠的12个月期间的2725名儿童单独研究与术后呕吐的关联。对选定结局变量评估芬太尼和酮咯酸的剂量反应关系。
与单药酮咯酸相比,双药治疗与最大FLACC = 0、最大FLACC评分7至10以及羟考酮补救的关联最为密切:优势比分别为4.89(95%置信区间[CI],4.04 - 5.93)、0.13(95% CI,0.10 - 0.16)和0.11(98.3% CI,0.09 - 0.14),每项P <.001)。发现年龄、西班牙裔种族、咪达唑仑和地点存在轻微关联,而性别或种族无关联。对于使用较高剂量芬太尼(≥1.5 μg/kg)和酮咯酸(≥0.75 mg/kg)治疗的受试者,90%无明显疼痛、躁动或痛苦。平均准备出院时间分别为21 ± 11分钟(酮咯酸)、26 ± 16分钟(芬太尼)和24 ± 14分钟(双药)(P <.0001)。酮咯酸组(2.7%)与双药治疗组(4.5%)的术后呕吐发生率无差异(P = 0.08)。
在这项大型回顾性儿科BMT研究中,肌肉注射芬太尼/酮咯酸联合使用与PACU更好的镇痛效果以及减少羟考酮补救需求密切相关,且恢复时间或呕吐发生率无临床显著增加。1.5至2 μg/kg芬太尼与1 mg/kg酮咯酸联合使用与最佳结局相关。双药治疗在欧洲白种人、非洲裔或西班牙裔儿童中似乎同样有效。