Kedia Ronak, Dargan Chandni, Hassan Omar, Dasa Vinod
Department of Surgery, University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, IL.
Department of Pediatrics, Palmetto Health Children's Hospital, Columbia, SC.
Ochsner J. 2016 Winter;16(4):457-463.
Patient satisfaction has become a significant factor in reimbursement schedules for physicians. A matter of debate is whether the patient's perception of time spent with the physician improves patient satisfaction. We sought to determine whether patient-physican time correlates with patient satisfaction and which factors are associated with patient perception of time.
A total of 73 patients who presented for an initial evaluation of knee osteoarthritis were evaluated by the same orthopedic surgeon at an outpatient clinic in New Orleans, LA. Each encounter was timed with a stopwatch. After the physician encounter, patients were asked to fill out a questionnaire assessing their perception of time spent with the physician, subjective pain, satisfaction with the visit, and understanding of the diagnosis and treatment plan. Patients were also asked to complete 4 functionality surveys. Radiographs of the patients' knees were taken and quantified using Kellgren-Lawrence and Ahlbäck grading scales.
We noted no relationship between patient satisfaction and patients' perception of time spent with the physician. Patients perceived their time with the physician to be an average of 6.5 minutes more than the actual time. However, patients who reported higher subjective pain scores (>7 on a 10-point scale) misestimated their time with the physician by nearly 96%, while patients with lower subjective pain scores (<7 on a 10-point scale) misestimated their time with the physician by only 54% (<0.007). We discovered similar findings in patients with worse Kellgren-Lawrence radiographic scores as well as worse Oxford Knee Scores and Knee injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Scores. The actual time spent was not different among patients.
Patients with greater subjective pain and worse functional status and patients with worse radiographic severity of knee osteoarthritis perceived greater time spent with the physician. However, no relationship between these variables and patient satisfaction scores was seen.
患者满意度已成为医生报销计划中的一个重要因素。一个有争议的问题是患者对与医生相处时间的感知是否会提高患者满意度。我们试图确定患者与医生相处的时间是否与患者满意度相关,以及哪些因素与患者对时间的感知有关。
在路易斯安那州新奥尔良的一家门诊诊所,同一位骨科医生对总共73名前来进行膝关节骨关节炎初次评估的患者进行了评估。每次会诊都用秒表计时。在与医生会诊后,要求患者填写一份问卷,评估他们对与医生相处时间的感知、主观疼痛、对就诊的满意度以及对诊断和治疗计划的理解。还要求患者完成4项功能调查。拍摄患者膝盖的X光片,并使用凯尔格伦 - 劳伦斯(Kellgren-Lawrence)和阿尔贝克(Ahlbäck)分级量表进行量化。
我们发现患者满意度与患者对与医生相处时间的感知之间没有关系。患者认为他们与医生相处的时间比实际时间平均多6.5分钟。然而,报告主观疼痛评分较高(10分制中>7分)的患者对与医生相处时间的估计误差近96%,而主观疼痛评分较低(10分制中<7分)的患者对与医生相处时间的估计误差仅为54%(<0.007)。在凯尔格伦 - 劳伦斯X光评分较差以及牛津膝关节评分和膝关节损伤与骨关节炎疗效评分较差的患者中,我们也发现了类似的结果。患者之间的实际相处时间没有差异。
主观疼痛更严重、功能状态更差以及膝关节骨关节炎放射学严重程度更差的患者认为与医生相处的时间更长。然而,未发现这些变量与患者满意度评分之间存在关系。