Nguyen Phuong Hong, Headey Derek, Frongillo Edward A, Tran Lan Mai, Rawat Rahul, Ruel Marie T, Menon Purnima
Poverty, Health, and Nutrition Division, International Food Policy Research Institute, Washington, DC;
Poverty, Health, and Nutrition Division, International Food Policy Research Institute, Washington, DC.
J Nutr. 2017 Mar;147(3):462-469. doi: 10.3945/jn.116.243949. Epub 2017 Jan 25.
Child linear growth sometimes improves in both intervention and comparison groups in evaluations of nutrition interventions, possibly because of spillover intervention effects to nonintervention areas or improvements in underlying determinants of nutritional change in both areas. We aimed to understand what changes in underlying socioeconomic characteristics and behavioral factors are important in explaining improvements in child linear growth. Baseline (2010) and endline (2014) surveys from the Alive & Thrive impact evaluation were used to identify the underlying determinants of height-for-age scores (HAZs) among children aged 24-48 mo in Bangladesh ( = 4311) and 24-59 mo in Vietnam ( = 4002). Oaxaca-Blinder regression decompositions were used to examine which underlying determinants contributed to HAZ changes over time. HAZs improved significantly between 2010 and 2014 in Bangladesh (∼0.18 SDs) and Vietnam (0.25 SDs). Underlying determinants improved substantially over time and were larger in Vietnam than in Bangladesh. Multiple regression models revealed significant associations between changes in HAZs and socioeconomic status (SES), food security, maternal education, hygiene, and birth weight in both countries. Changes in HAZs were significantly associated with maternal nutrition knowledge and child dietary diversity in Bangladesh, and with prenatal visits in Vietnam. Improvements in maternal nutrition knowledge in Bangladesh accounted for 20% of the total HAZ change, followed by maternal education (13%), SES (12%), hygiene (10%), and food security (9%). HAZ improvements in Vietnam were accounted for by changes in SES (26%), prenatal visits (25%), hygiene (19%), child birth weight (10%), and maternal education (7%). The decomposition models in both countries performed well, explaining >75% of the HAZ changes. Decomposition is a useful and simple technique for analyzing nonintervention drivers of nutritional change in intervention and comparison areas. Improvements in underlying determinants explained rapid improvements in HAZs between 2010 and 2014 in Bangladesh and Vietnam.
在营养干预评估中,干预组和对照组儿童的线性生长有时都会有所改善,这可能是因为干预效应溢出到了非干预地区,或者是两个地区营养变化的潜在决定因素都得到了改善。我们旨在了解潜在的社会经济特征和行为因素的哪些变化对于解释儿童线性生长的改善很重要。“茁壮成长”影响评估中的基线(2010年)和终线(2014年)调查被用于确定孟加拉国24至48个月大儿童(n = 4311)和越南24至59个月大儿童(n = 4002)年龄别身高得分(HAZ)的潜在决定因素。采用奥克萨卡-布林德回归分解法来检验哪些潜在决定因素导致了HAZ随时间的变化。2010年至2014年期间,孟加拉国(约0.18标准差)和越南(0.25标准差)的HAZ显著改善。随着时间的推移,潜在决定因素有了实质性改善,越南的改善幅度大于孟加拉国。多元回归模型显示,两个国家HAZ的变化与社会经济地位(SES)、粮食安全、母亲教育程度、卫生条件和出生体重之间存在显著关联。在孟加拉国,HAZ的变化与母亲的营养知识和儿童饮食多样性显著相关,在越南则与产前检查显著相关。孟加拉国母亲营养知识的改善占HAZ总变化的20%,其次是母亲教育程度(13%)、SES(12%)、卫生条件(10%)和粮食安全(9%)。越南HAZ的改善归因于SES的变化(26%)、产前检查(25%)、卫生条件(19%)、儿童出生体重(10%)和母亲教育程度(7%)。两国的分解模型效果良好,解释了超过75%的HAZ变化。分解是一种有用且简单的技术,可用于分析干预地区和对照地区营养变化的非干预驱动因素。潜在决定因素的改善解释了2010年至2014年期间孟加拉国和越南HAZ的快速改善。