Howes Erica, Boushey Carol J, Kerr Deborah A, Tomayko Emily J, Cluskey Mary
College of Public Health and Human Sciences, Nutrition, Oregon State University, 101 Milam Hall, Corvallis, OR 97331-3303, USA.
Epidemiology Program, University of Hawaii Cancer Center, Honolulu, HI 96813, USA.
Nutrients. 2017 Feb 7;9(2):114. doi: 10.3390/nu9020114.
Image-based dietary assessment (IBDA) may improve the accuracy of dietary assessments, but no formalized training currently exists for skills relating to IBDA. This study investigated nutrition and dietetics students' and interns' IBDA abilities, the training and experience factors that may contribute to food identification and quantification accuracy, and the perceived challenges to performing IBDA. An online survey containing images of known foods and serving sizes representing common American foods was used to assess the ability to identify foods and serving sizes. Nutrition and dietetics students and interns from the United States and Australia ( = 114) accurately identified foods 79.5% of the time. Quantification accuracy was lower, with only 38% of estimates within ±10% of the actual weight. Foods of amorphous shape or higher energy density had the highest percent error. Students expressed general difficulty with perceiving serving sizes, making IBDA food quantification more difficult. Experience cooking at home from a recipe, frequent measuring of portions, and having a food preparation or cooking laboratory class were associated with enhanced accuracy in IBDA. Future training of dietetics students should incorporate more food-based serving size training to improve quantification accuracy while performing IBDA, while advances in IBDA technology are also needed.
基于图像的饮食评估(IBDA)可能会提高饮食评估的准确性,但目前尚无针对IBDA相关技能的正规培训。本研究调查了营养与饮食专业学生及实习生的IBDA能力、可能有助于食物识别和定量准确性的培训和经验因素,以及进行IBDA时所感知到的挑战。一项包含代表常见美国食物的已知食物和份量图像的在线调查被用于评估识别食物和份量的能力。来自美国和澳大利亚的营养与饮食专业学生及实习生(n = 114)在79.5%的情况下能准确识别食物。定量准确性较低,只有38%的估计值在实际重量的±10%范围内。形状不规则或能量密度较高的食物误差百分比最高。学生们表示在感知份量方面普遍存在困难,这使得IBDA食物定量更加困难。在家按照食谱烹饪的经验、频繁测量份量以及参加食物制备或烹饪实验室课程与IBDA中更高的准确性相关。未来对饮食专业学生的培训应纳入更多基于食物的份量训练,以提高在进行IBDA时的定量准确性,同时也需要IBDA技术的进步。