Youssef Nagy A, McCall W Vaughn, Andrade Chittaranjan
Department of Psychiatry and Health Behavior, The Medical College of Georgia, Augusta University, Augusta, GA, USA. E-mail:
Ann Clin Psychiatry. 2017 Feb;29(1):62-70.
Posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is associated with a high burden of disability and mortality and frequently is treatment resistant. There is little to offer patients who are not responding to standard interventions. Thus, the objective of this report is to systematically review human data on whether electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) is effective in PTSD.
We performed a systematic literature review from 1958 through August 2016 for clinical studies and case reports published in English examining the efficacy of ECT in improving PTSD symptoms.
The literature search generated 3 retrospective studies, 1 prospective uncontrolled clinical trial, and 5 case reports. It is not clear, given the small sample size and lack of a large randomized trial, whether favorable outcomes were attributed to improvement in depression (as opposed to core PTSD symptoms).
Current efficacy data do not separate conclusively the effects of ECT on PTSD symptoms from those on depression. Randomized controlled trials are necessary to examine the use of ECT in medication-refractory PTSD patients with and without comorbid depression. Subsequent studies may address response in PTSD subtypes, and the use of novel techniques, such as memory reactivation, before ECT.
创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)与高残疾负担和死亡率相关,且常常对治疗有抵抗性。对于那些对标准干预措施无反应的患者,几乎没有其他办法。因此,本报告的目的是系统回顾关于电休克疗法(ECT)治疗PTSD是否有效的人体数据。
我们对1958年至2016年8月期间以英文发表的关于ECT改善PTSD症状疗效的临床研究和病例报告进行了系统的文献综述。
文献检索产生了3项回顾性研究、1项前瞻性非对照临床试验和5例病例报告。鉴于样本量小且缺乏大型随机试验,尚不清楚良好的结果是归因于抑郁的改善(相对于PTSD核心症状而言)。
目前的疗效数据并未明确区分ECT对PTSD症状和抑郁症状的影响。有必要进行随机对照试验,以研究ECT在伴有或不伴有共病抑郁的药物难治性PTSD患者中的应用。后续研究可探讨PTSD亚型的反应,以及在ECT之前使用记忆再激活等新技术的情况。