Zee R S, Herndon C D Anthony, Cooper C S, Kim C, McKenna P H, Khoury A, Herbst K W
Department of Urology, University of Virginia School of Medicine, Charlottesville, VA, USA.
Department of Surgery, Virginia Commonwealth University School of Medicine, Richmond, VA, USA.
J Pediatr Urol. 2017 Jun;13(3):316.e1-316.e5. doi: 10.1016/j.jpurol.2016.12.012. Epub 2017 Jan 19.
The resolution rate of prenatal urinary tract dilation (UTD) has been documented in several retrospective studies. The present study analyzed prospective observational registry data, with the aim of determining time to resolution among patients prenatally identified with mild postnatal UTD.
A total of 248 subjects, from four centers, were prospectively enrolled from 2008 to 2015. Exclusion criteria included other anomalies (n = 69), fewer than two ultrasounds, and/or <3 months follow-up (n = 26). Resolution was defined as Outcome A (SFU 0) and Outcome B (SFU 0/1). Fisher's exact test, Mann-Whitney U or Kruskal-Wallis test and Kaplan-Meier were used for analysis.
RESULTS/DISCUSSION: The median follow-up for 179 (n = 137 males) subjects was 15 months (IQR 7-24), range 0-56 months. VCUG was performed in 100 (57%) and VUR identified in 15 (15%). There was no association with reflux and resolution (P = 0.72). For resolution assessment (n = 153), lower grades were likely to resolve and demonstrated a higher rate in the Outcome B classification. Time to resolution also favored lower grades, with the majority resolving within 2 years (Figure). Surgical intervention was performed in 14 (8%). It is interesting to note that regardless of grade of UTD, there was no difference in frequency of US or the time that RUS was first performed. Practitioners performed the first RUS of life within a narrow window ranging from 0.27 RUS/month for Grade 1 UTD to 0.30 RUS/month for Grade 4 UTD. It was speculated that this practice pattern occurrence likely reflected the deficiency in knowledge by primary care providers, and identified a potential opportunity for education. The SFU registry substantiates that the vast majority of patients will demonstrate transient UTD and most cases that do not resolve will improve within 2 years of life. This data could be used to further an evidenced-based approach towards the evaluation and management of prenatal UTD, as outlined in the multidisciplinary consensus statement for prenatal urinary tract dilation.
This prospective registry confirms that the majority of prenatal UTD is transient, resolution occurs within the first 3 years of life, and most patients will not need intervention. Redefining SFU 1 as normal increased the resolution rate. A large proportion of patients were not evaluated with a VCUG, therefore impact of VUR could not be determined.
多项回顾性研究记录了产前泌尿道扩张(UTD)的消退率。本研究分析了前瞻性观察登记数据,旨在确定产前诊断为轻度产后UTD的患者的消退时间。
2008年至2015年,前瞻性纳入了来自四个中心的248名受试者。排除标准包括其他异常(n = 69)、超声检查少于两次和/或随访时间<3个月(n = 26)。消退定义为结果A(SFU 0)和结果B(SFU 0/1)。采用Fisher精确检验、Mann-Whitney U检验或Kruskal-Wallis检验以及Kaplan-Meier分析。
结果/讨论:179名(n = 137名男性)受试者的中位随访时间为15个月(IQR 7 - 24),范围为0 - 56个月。100名(57%)患者进行了排尿性膀胱尿道造影(VCUG),其中15名(15%)发现有膀胱输尿管反流(VUR)。反流与消退之间无相关性(P = 0.72)。对于消退评估(n = 153),较低分级的UTD更有可能消退,且在结果B分类中显示出更高的消退率。消退时间也有利于较低分级,大多数在2年内消退(图)。14名(8%)患者接受了手术干预。值得注意的是,无论UTD分级如何,超声检查的频率或首次进行肾膀胱超声(RUS)的时间均无差异。从业者在较窄的时间范围内进行了首次RUS,从1级UTD的每月0.27次RUS到4级UTD的每月0.30次RUS。据推测,这种实践模式的出现可能反映了初级保健提供者知识的不足,并确定了一个潜在的教育机会。SFU登记证实,绝大多数患者的UTD是暂时的,大多数未消退的病例在出生后2年内会有所改善。这些数据可用于进一步推进基于证据的产前UTD评估和管理方法,如产前泌尿道扩张的多学科共识声明中所述。
这项前瞻性登记证实,大多数产前UTD是暂时的,在生命的前3年内消退,大多数患者不需要干预。将SFU 1重新定义为正常可提高消退率。很大一部分患者未进行VCUG评估,因此无法确定VUR的影响。