Lakhotia Devendra, Swaminathan Siva, Shon Won Yong, Oh Jong Keon, Moon Jun Gyu, Dwivedi Chirayu, Hong Suk Joo
Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Korea University Guro Hospital, Seoul, Korea.
Department of Radiology, Korea University Guro Hospital, Seoul, Korea.
Clin Orthop Surg. 2017 Mar;9(1):29-36. doi: 10.4055/cios.2017.9.1.29. Epub 2017 Feb 13.
Transtrochanteric rotational osteotomy (TRO) is a controversial hip-preserving procedure with a variable success rate. The healing process of femoral head osteonecrosis after TRO has been poorly explained till now. This study aimed to evaluate the healing process of previously transposed necrotic lesion after a TRO for nontraumatic osteonecrosis of the femoral head using computed tomography (CT).
Among 52 patients (58 hips) who had preserved original femoral head after TRO, we retrospectively reviewed 27 patients (28 hips) who had undergone sequential CT scans and had no major complication following TRO. The average age was 34 years (range, 18 to 59 years). The mean follow-up period was 9.1 years. We evaluated the reparative process of the transposed osteonecrotic lesion with CT scans.
Plain radiographs of the osteonecrotic lesion revealed sclerotic and lucent changes in 14 hips (50%) and normal bony architecture in the other 14 hips (50%) at the final follow-up. CT scans of the osteonecrotic lesions showed cystic changes with heterogeneous sclerosis in 13 hips (46%), normal trabecular bone with or without small cysts in 9 hips (32%), and fragmentation of the necrotic lesion in 6 hips (22%). Seventeen hips (60%) showed minimal (13 hips) to mild (4 hips) nonprogressive collapse of the transposed osteonecrotic area. The collapse of the transposed osteonecrotic area on the CT scan was significantly associated with the healing pattern ( = 0.009), as all 6 patients (6 hips) with fragmentation of the necrotic lesion had minimal (5 hips) to mild (1 hip) collapse. Furthermore, a significant association was found between the collapse of the transposed osteonecrotic area on the CT scan of 17 hips (60%) and postoperative Harris hip score ( = 0.021). We observed no differences among the healing patterns on CT scans with regard to age, gender, etiology, staging, preoperative lesion type, preoperative intact area, percentage of necrotic area, direction of rotation and immediate postoperative intact area.
The majority of the hips showed incomplete regeneration of the transposed osteonecrotic lesion with cysts, sclerosis, and fragmentation, whereas repair with normal trabecular bone was observed only in one-third of the hips that were preserved after Sugioka TRO.
转子间旋转截骨术(TRO)是一种存在争议的保髋手术,成功率各异。迄今为止,TRO术后股骨头坏死的愈合过程鲜有合理解释。本研究旨在运用计算机断层扫描(CT)评估TRO治疗非创伤性股骨头坏死术后先前移位坏死病灶的愈合过程。
在52例(58髋)TRO术后保留原股骨头的患者中,我们回顾性分析了27例(28髋)接受了序贯CT扫描且TRO术后无重大并发症的患者。平均年龄为34岁(范围18至59岁)。平均随访期为9.1年。我们通过CT扫描评估移位骨坏死病灶的修复过程。
在末次随访时,骨坏死病灶平片显示14髋(50%)有硬化和透亮改变,另14髋(50%)骨结构正常。骨坏死病灶的CT扫描显示,13髋(46%)有囊性改变伴不均匀硬化,9髋(32%)有正常小梁骨,有或无小囊肿,6髋(22%)坏死病灶有碎裂。17髋(60%)显示移位骨坏死区域有轻微(13髋)至轻度(4髋)的非进行性塌陷。CT扫描上移位骨坏死区域坍塌与愈合模式显著相关(P = 0.009),因为所有6例(6髋)坏死病灶碎裂的患者均有轻微(5髋)至轻度(1髋)塌陷。此外,17髋(60%)CT扫描上移位骨坏死区域的坍塌与术后Harris髋关节评分显著相关(P = 0.021)。我们观察到,在CT扫描的愈合模式方面,年龄、性别、病因、分期、术前病灶类型、术前完整区域、坏死区域百分比、旋转方向和术后即刻完整区域之间无差异。
大多数髋部显示移位骨坏死病灶不完全再生,伴有囊肿、硬化和碎裂,而仅在三分之一接受杉冈TRO术后保留的髋部中观察到正常小梁骨修复。