Department of Oncology, University of Torino, AOU San Luigi di Orbassano, Orbassano, Italy.
AO Ordine Mariziano, Torino, Italy.
Clin Colorectal Cancer. 2017 Dec;16(4):372-376. doi: 10.1016/j.clcc.2017.03.019. Epub 2017 Apr 8.
The optimal therapeutic strategy for metastatic colorectal cancer patients is still a matter of debate. There are no prognostic variables indicating how many lines individual patients ought to receive, and whether later lines could be effective even when earlier ones were not.
We retrospectively collected data from 420 consecutive patients with metastatic colorectal cancer at our institution, describing the proportion of patients who received second or later lines of therapy and the chance of a line of treatment being active when the previous line was not. For each line of treatment, we defined clinical benefit as the probability of not having had evidence of disease progression 6 months after the start of chemotherapy.
Of the 373 patients with disease progression after first-line chemotherapy (1L), 277 received a second line (2L) (probability of being submitted to a 2L (P(2L)) = 74.3%): 143 (63.3%) of 226 received a 3L (P(3L)), and 56 (45.9%) of 122 were submitted to a 4L (P(4L)). Joint probabilities were: 2L 74.3%, 3L 47.0%, and 4L 21.6%. A total of 298 (71.5%) of 417 patients had a clinical benefit with 1L; 134 (48.6%) of 276 with 2L; 50 (35.2%) of 142 with 3L; and 12 (25.0%) of 48 with 4L. Taking all these data together, 31% of the patients who experienced early progression at 1L had the chance to have a clinical benefit with any further lines.
Our study demonstrated that of 4 patients submitted to a 1L, about 3 will receive a 2L, about 2 a 3L, and nearly 1 a 4L. Later lines could be beneficial even though earlier ones were not.
转移性结直肠癌患者的最佳治疗策略仍存在争议。目前尚无预后变量可以指示个体患者应接受多少线治疗,也无法预测先前的治疗线无效时,后续的治疗线是否有效。
我们回顾性地收集了我院 420 例转移性结直肠癌患者的数据,描述了接受二线或更后线治疗的患者比例,以及在先前治疗线无效时,治疗线有效的机会。对于每一线治疗,我们将临床获益定义为化疗开始后 6 个月无疾病进展的概率。
在接受一线化疗(1L)后疾病进展的 373 例患者中,277 例(277/373,74.3%)接受了二线治疗(2L):其中 143 例(143/226,63.3%)接受了三线治疗(3L),56 例(56/122,45.9%)接受了四线治疗(4L)。联合概率为:2L 为 74.3%,3L 为 47.0%,4L 为 21.6%。417 例患者中,共有 298 例(298/417,71.5%)有 1L 的临床获益;276 例患者中有 134 例(134/276,48.6%)有 2L 的临床获益;142 例患者中有 50 例(50/142,35.2%)有 3L 的临床获益;48 例患者中有 12 例(12/48,25.0%)有 4L 的临床获益。综合所有这些数据,在 1L 早期进展的患者中,约有 30%的患者有机会从进一步的治疗线中获益。
我们的研究表明,在接受一线治疗的 4 例患者中,约有 3 例将接受二线治疗,约有 2 例将接受三线治疗,近 1 例将接受四线治疗。即使先前的治疗线无效,后续的治疗线也可能有效。