Fernando Delihta, Attik Nina, Pradelle-Plasse Nelly, Jackson Phil, Grosgogeat Brigitte, Colon Pierre
Laboratoire des Multimatériaux et Interface, Université Claude Bernard Lyon 1, Lyon, France.
Laboratoire des Multimatériaux et Interface, Université Claude Bernard Lyon 1, Lyon, France; Faculté d'Odontologie, Université Claude Bernard Lyon 1, Lyon, France.
Mater Sci Eng C Mater Biol Appl. 2017 Jul 1;76:1369-1377. doi: 10.1016/j.msec.2017.03.083. Epub 2017 Mar 14.
Strategies to achieve dentin remineralization is at present an important target of restorative dentistry. Remineralization of dentin by a bioactive material is complete only when the tissue regains its functionality. This is achieved when there is adequate apatite formation which most importantly translates into improved mechanical properties of dentin as a result of intrafibrillar mineralization. Bioactive glass (BAG) is a well-known implant material for bone regeneration and is proven to have excellent ability of apatite formation. Hence, recent studies have proposed BAGs as one of the most desired materials for remineralization of dentin. Therefore the aim of this systematic review was to scope the evidence of bioactive glass to remineralize dentin.
The following research question was formulated: "Is there strong evidence for bioactive glass to remineralize dentin?" Three databases (Web of science, PubMed and Science direct) were scanned independently following PRISMA guidelines. Inclusion and exclusion criteria were set to identify relevant articles based on title and abstract screening. Finally, potentially relevant articles were downloaded and the full text was scrutinized to select the articles included in this review.
The first phase of search returned 303 articles. A total of 19 papers with full text were scrutinized for inclusion, of which 3 papers were chosen for the final synthesis. All three studies confirm that BAG treatment leads to enhanced apatite formation in dentin. Only 1 of the 3 studies has reported the mechanical properties of dentin after BAG treatment and it revealed that the Young's modulus and flexural bend strength of BAG treated dentin were much lower than natural dentin even though they had similar apatite content.
This review highlights the importance of assessing the mechanical properties of dentin alongside to the newly formed apatite content in order to prove BAGs efficiency to remineralize this tissue. Though studies have confirmed that BAGs stimulate excellent apatite formation in dentin, it should be concluded that there isn't sufficient evidence for bioactive glass to effectively remineralize this tissue as the mechanical properties of the BAG treated dentin haven't been well explored.
实现牙本质再矿化的策略是目前修复牙科的一个重要目标。生物活性材料使牙本质再矿化只有在组织恢复其功能时才算完成。当有足够的磷灰石形成时就能实现这一点,最重要的是,由于纤维内矿化,牙本质的机械性能得到改善。生物活性玻璃(BAG)是一种著名的用于骨再生的植入材料,并且已被证明具有优异的磷灰石形成能力。因此,最近的研究提出将生物活性玻璃作为牙本质再矿化最理想的材料之一。因此,本系统评价的目的是梳理生物活性玻璃使牙本质再矿化的证据。
提出了以下研究问题:“是否有充分证据表明生物活性玻璃能使牙本质再矿化?”按照PRISMA指南独立检索了三个数据库(科学网、PubMed和科学Direct)。设定了纳入和排除标准,以便根据标题和摘要筛选来识别相关文章。最后,下载了潜在相关文章,并对全文进行了审查,以选择纳入本评价的文章。
检索的第一阶段返回了303篇文章。共对19篇全文进行了纳入审查,其中3篇文章被选入最终综述。所有三项研究均证实,生物活性玻璃处理可导致牙本质中磷灰石形成增加。三项研究中只有一项报告了生物活性玻璃处理后牙本质的机械性能,结果显示,尽管生物活性玻璃处理的牙本质与天然牙本质的磷灰石含量相似,但其杨氏模量和抗弯强度远低于天然牙本质。
本综述强调了在评估生物活性玻璃使该组织再矿化的效率时,除了评估新形成的磷灰石含量外,还需评估牙本质机械性能的重要性。尽管研究证实生物活性玻璃能刺激牙本质中优异的磷灰石形成,但由于生物活性玻璃处理的牙本质的机械性能尚未得到充分研究,因此应得出结论,没有足够的证据表明生物活性玻璃能有效使该组织再矿化。