Xue W, Vegunta S, Zwart C M, Aguilar M I, Patel A C, Hoxworth J M, Demaerschalk B M, Mitchell J R
From the Department of Biomedical Informatics (W.X., J.R.M.), Arizona State University, Scottsdale, Arizona.
Moran Eye Center (S.V.), University of Utah, Salt Lake City, Utah.
AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2017 Aug;38(8):1536-1542. doi: 10.3174/ajnr.A5256. Epub 2017 Jun 8.
Intracerebral hemorrhage accounts for 6.5%-19.6% of all acute strokes. Initial intracerebral hemorrhage volume and expansion are both independent predictors of clinical outcomes and mortality. Therefore, a rapid, unbiased, and precise measurement of intracerebral hemorrhage volume is a key component of clinical management. The most commonly used method, ABC/2, results in overestimation. We developed an interactive segmentation program, SegTool, using a novel graphic processing unit, level set algorithm. Until now, the speed, bias, and precision of SegTool had not been validated.
In a single stroke academic center, 2 vascular neurologists and 2 neuroradiologists independently performed a test-retest experiment that involved repeat measurements of static, unchanging intracerebral hemorrhage volumes on CT from 76 intracerebral hemorrhage cases. Measurements were made with SegTool and ABC/2. True intracerebral hemorrhage volumes were estimated from a consensus of repeat manual tracings by 2 operators. These data allowed us to estimate measurement bias, precision, and speed.
The measurements with SegTool were not significantly different from the true intracerebral hemorrhage volumes, while ABC/2 overestimated volume by 45%. The interrater measurement variability with SegTool was 50% less than that with ABC/2. The average measurement times for ABC/2 and SegTool were 35.7 and 44.6 seconds, respectively.
SegTool appears to have attributes superior to ABC/2 in terms of accuracy and interrater reliability with a 9-second delay in measurement time (on average); hence, it could be useful in clinical trials and practice.
脑出血占所有急性卒中的6.5%-19.6%。初始脑出血体积和血肿扩大都是临床结局和死亡率的独立预测因素。因此,快速、无偏且精确地测量脑出血体积是临床管理的关键组成部分。最常用的方法ABC/2会导致高估。我们使用一种新颖的图形处理单元水平集算法开发了一个交互式分割程序SegTool。到目前为止,SegTool的速度、偏差和精度尚未得到验证。
在一个单一的卒中学术中心,2名血管神经科医生和2名神经放射科医生独立进行了一项重测实验,该实验涉及对76例脑出血病例的CT上静态、不变的脑出血体积进行重复测量。使用SegTool和ABC/2进行测量。通过2名操作人员重复手动描记的共识来估计真正的脑出血体积。这些数据使我们能够估计测量偏差、精度和速度。
SegTool的测量结果与真正的脑出血体积无显著差异,而ABC/2高估了45%。SegTool的评分者间测量变异性比ABC/2小50%。ABC/2和SegTool的平均测量时间分别为35.7秒和44.6秒。
SegTool在准确性和评分者间可靠性方面似乎具有优于ABC/2的属性,测量时间平均延迟9秒;因此,它可能在临床试验和实践中有用。