Barros Geisa Baptista, Lemos Elenice Moreira, E Silva-Dos-Santos Priscila Pinto, Dietze Reynaldo, Zandonade Eliana, Mineo José Roberto, de Oliveira Silva Deise Aparecida, Pajuaba Ana Cláudia Marquez, de Souza Gomes Matheus, do Amaral Laurence Rodrigues, Coelho-Dos-Reis Jordana Grazziela, Martins-Filho Olindo Assis, Serufo José Carlos
Departamento de Pediatria, Universidade Federal do Espírito Santo, Vitória, Espírito Santo, Brazil.
Núcleo de Doenças Infecciosas, Universidade Federal do Espírito Santo, Vitória, Espírito Santo, Brazil.
J Immunol Methods. 2017 Dec;451:61-70. doi: 10.1016/j.jim.2017.08.010. Epub 2017 Sep 4.
Serological tests available for the diagnosis of acute Toxoplasma gondii infection have limitations in establishing the temporal diagnosis of acute toxoplasmosis. The present analytical-descriptive investigation comprises of a prospective longitudinal cohort study to search for accurate biomarkers to distinguish acute, early and late convalescent T. gondii infection. Classic methods (immunofluorescence-IFA along with Enzyme-linked immunosorbent-ELISA and fluorescent-ELFA assays) for IgM, IgA, IgG and IgG avidity were employed in parallel with flow cytometry-based anti-fixed T. gondii tachyzoites serology (FC-AFTA-IgM, IgG, IgG avidity and IgG subclasses). The results reemphasized the limitations of IgM & IgG IFA, IgG ELFA, IgG & IgG subclasses FC as well as IgA ELISA biomarkers for the temporal diagnosis of acute toxoplasmosis. Receiver Operating-characteristics features (ROC-curves) were employed to adjust conventional cut-offs aiming at establishing a novel protocol to discriminate more accurately the different phases of toxoplasmosis. Conversely, IgM presented high diagnostic co-positivity for acute toxoplasmosis (97% for ELISA, 96% for ELFA and 95% for FC-AFTA) along with moderate co-negativity for detection of late convalescent toxoplasmosis (82%, 76% and 79%, respectively). IgG avidity (ELFA and FC-AFTA) outstand with the highest performance indices with 91% and 96% co-negativity for assessing acute toxoplasmosis and 91% and 98% co-positivity for late convalescent toxoplasmosis, respectively. Multivariate analysis generated a three-step algorithm comprising IgM ELFA screening followed by ELFA and FC-AFTA IgG avidity with high accuracy in discriminating acute from late convalescent infection. Together, these findings demonstrate the applicability of the proposed panel of diagnostic tools for accurate temporal classification of T. gondii infection.
可用于诊断急性弓形虫感染的血清学检测在确定急性弓形虫病的时间诊断方面存在局限性。本分析性描述性研究包括一项前瞻性纵向队列研究,以寻找准确的生物标志物来区分急性、早期和晚期恢复期弓形虫感染。采用经典方法(免疫荧光 - IFA 以及酶联免疫吸附 - ELISA 和荧光 - ELFA 检测)检测 IgM、IgA、IgG 和 IgG 亲和力,并与基于流式细胞术的抗固定弓形虫速殖子血清学(FC - AFTA - IgM、IgG、IgG 亲和力和 IgG 亚类)并行使用。结果再次强调了 IgM 和 IgG IFA、IgG ELFA、IgG 和 IgG 亚类 FC 以及 IgA ELISA 生物标志物在急性弓形虫病时间诊断方面的局限性。采用受试者操作特征(ROC)曲线来调整传统临界值,旨在建立一种新方案,以更准确地区分弓形虫病的不同阶段。相反,IgM 对急性弓形虫病呈现出较高的诊断共阳性率(ELISA 为 97%,ELFA 为 96%,FC - AFTA 为 95%),同时对晚期恢复期弓形虫病检测的共阴性率适中(分别为 82%、76%和 79%)。IgG 亲和力(ELFA 和 FC - AFTA)表现突出,性能指标最高,评估急性弓形虫病时共阴性率分别为 91%和 96%,评估晚期恢复期弓形虫病时共阳性率分别为 91%和 98%。多变量分析生成了一种三步算法,包括 IgM ELFA 筛查,随后进行 ELFA 和 FC - AFTA IgG 亲和力检测,在区分急性感染和晚期恢复期感染方面具有很高的准确性。总之,这些发现证明了所提出的诊断工具组合在准确进行弓形虫感染时间分类方面的适用性。