Likova Lora T, Tyler Christopher W, Cacciamani Laura, Mineff Kristyo, Nicholas Spero
The Smith-Kettlewell Eye Institute, San Francisco, CA, USA.
IS&T Int Symp Electron Imaging. 2016;2016. doi: 10.2352/ISSN.2470-1173.2016.16.HVEI-095. Epub 2016 Feb 14.
Fundamental forms of high-order cognition, such as reading and writing, are usually studied in the context of one modality - vision. People without sight, however, use the kinesthetic-based Braille writing, and haptic-based Braille reading. We asked whether the cognitive and motor control mechanisms underlying writing and reading are modality-specific or supramodal. While a number of previous functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI) studies have investigated the brain network for Braille reading in the blind, such studies on Braille writing are lacking. Consequently, no comparative network analysis of Braille writing vs. reading exists. Here, we report the first study of Braille writing, and a comparison of the brain organization for Braille writing vs Braille reading. FMRI was conducted in a Siemens 3T Trio scanner. Our custom MRI-compatible drawing/writing lectern was further modified to provide for Braille reading and writing. Each of five paragraphs of novel Braille text describing objects, faces and navigation sequences was read, then reproduced twice by Braille writing from memory, then read a second time. During Braille reading, the haptic-sensing of the Braille letters strongly activated not only the early visual area V1 and V2, but some highly specialized areas, such as the classical visual grapheme area and the Exner motor grapheme area. Braille-writing-from-memory, engaged a significantly more extensive network in dorsal motor, somatosensory/kinesthetic, dorsal parietal and prefrontal cortex. However, in contrast to the largely extended V1 activation in drawing-from-memory in the blind after training (Likova, 2012), Braille writing from memory generated focal activation restricted to the most foveal part of V1, presumably reflecting topographically the focal demands of such a "pin-pricking" task.
诸如阅读和写作等高阶认知的基本形式,通常是在单一模态——视觉的背景下进行研究的。然而,盲人使用基于动觉的盲文书写以及基于触觉的盲文阅读。我们探讨了写作和阅读背后的认知与运动控制机制是特定于模态还是超模态的。尽管先前有许多功能磁共振成像(fMRI)研究调查了盲人阅读盲文的脑网络,但缺乏关于盲文书写的此类研究。因此,不存在对盲文书写与阅读的比较性网络分析。在此,我们报告了第一项关于盲文书写的研究,以及对盲文书写与盲文阅读的脑组织结构的比较。fMRI是在西门子3T Trio扫描仪中进行的。我们定制的与MRI兼容的绘图/书写讲台经过进一步改装,以实现盲文阅读和书写。五段描述物体、面孔和导航序列的新颖盲文文本中的每一段,先是被阅读,然后凭记忆通过盲文书写重现两次,接着再读一遍。在盲文阅读过程中,对盲文字母的触觉感知不仅强烈激活了早期视觉区域V1和V2,还激活了一些高度专门化的区域,如经典视觉字素区和埃克斯纳运动字素区。凭记忆进行盲文书写时,在背侧运动、体感/动觉、背侧顶叶和前额叶皮层中涉及的网络要广泛得多。然而,与训练后盲人凭记忆绘图时V1的大面积激活情况(利科娃,2012年)不同,凭记忆进行盲文书写产生的局灶性激活仅限于V1最中央凹的部分,大概从地形学上反映了这样一项“针刺”任务的局灶性需求。