Pan Er, Yu Jiangang, Zhang Shengchang, Nie Yunfei, Li Qin
Ann Plast Surg. 2018 Mar;80(3):242-244. doi: 10.1097/SAP.0000000000001250.
Several factors may influence aesthetic outcomes of ptosis surgery, especially in patients with asymmetrical ptosis. We retrospectively assessed the effect of Hering's law on surgical outcomes of patients with asymmetrical ptosis.
Patients with mild to moderate asymmetrical ptosis (N = 300) who underwent advancement or plication of upper eyelid aponeurosis between January 2014 and July 2016 were enrolled. Fifty patients (group A) underwent surgery without taking into consideration the impact of Hering's law. Of these, 35 patients with unilateral ptosis (subgroup A1) underwent standard surgery on the contralateral side, whereas 15 patients with bilateral ptosis (subgroup A2) were first operated on the milder side followed by the more severely affected side.In 250 patients (group B), surgery was performed taking cognizance of the implications of Hering's law. These included 100 patients with unilateral ptosis (B1) and 150 with bilateral ptosis (B2). Difference in bilateral palpebral fissure symmetry by less than 0.5 mm was considered as satisfactory outcome.
Duration of postoperative follow-up ranged from 3 to 24 months. Satisfactory outcomes were achieved over 60% of patients in group A (A1, 60.6%; A2, 66.67%) and in 96% of patients in group B (B1, 95%; B2, 96.67%). Patients with unsatisfactory outcomes underwent repair according to Hering's law after 3 months and obtained good results.
Application of Hering's law may improve outcomes of corrective surgery in patients with asymmetric ptosis.
多种因素可能影响上睑下垂手术的美学效果,尤其是在不对称性上睑下垂患者中。我们回顾性评估了赫林定律对上睑下垂患者手术效果的影响。
纳入2014年1月至2016年7月期间接受上睑提肌腱膜缩短或折叠术的轻至中度不对称性上睑下垂患者(N = 300例)。50例患者(A组)手术时未考虑赫林定律的影响。其中,35例单侧上睑下垂患者(A1亚组)对侧行标准手术,15例双侧上睑下垂患者(A2亚组)先在症状较轻一侧手术,然后再在症状较重一侧手术。250例患者(B组)手术时考虑了赫林定律的影响。其中包括100例单侧上睑下垂患者(B1)和150例双侧上睑下垂患者(B2)。双侧睑裂对称性差异小于0.5 mm被视为满意结果。
术后随访时间为3至24个月。A组超过60%的患者(A1,60.6%;A2,66.67%)和B组96%的患者(B1,95%;B2,96.67%)取得了满意的结果。结果不满意的患者在3个月后根据赫林定律进行修复,效果良好。
应用赫林定律可能改善不对称性上睑下垂患者矫正手术的效果。