Silva Walter, Das Tapas K, Izurieta Ricardo
Department of Industrial and Management System Engineering, University of South Florida, Tampa, FL, 33620, USA.
College of Public Health, University of South Florida, Tampa, FL, 33620, USA.
BMC Public Health. 2017 Nov 25;17(1):898. doi: 10.1186/s12889-017-4884-5.
Since spring 2013, periodic emergence of avian influenza A(H7N9) virus in China has heightened the concern for a possible pandemic outbreak among humans, though it is believed that the virus is not yet human-to-human transmittable. Till June 2017, A(H7N9) has resulted in 1533 laboratory-confirmed cases of human infections causing 592 deaths. The aim of this paper is to present disease burden estimates (measured by infection attack rates (IAR) and number of deaths) in the event of a possible pandemic outbreak caused by human-to-human transmission capability acquired by A(H7N9) virus. Even though such a pandemic will likely spread worldwide, our focus in this paper is to estimate the impact on the United States alone.
The method first uses a data clustering technique to divide 50 states in the U.S. into a small number of clusters. Thereafter, for a few selected states in each cluster, the method employs an agent-based (AB) model to simulate human A(H7N9) influenza pandemic outbreaks. The model uses demographic and epidemiological data. A few selected non-pharmaceutical intervention (NPI) measures are applied to mitigate the outbreaks. Disease burden for the U.S. is estimated by combining results from the clusters applying a method used in stratified sampling.
Two possible pandemic scenarios with R = 1.5 and 1.8 are examined. Infection attack rates with 95% C.I. (Confidence Interval) for R = 1.5 and 1.8 are estimated to be 18.78% (17.3-20.27) and 25.05% (23.11-26.99), respectively. The corresponding number of deaths (95% C.I.), per 100,000, are 7252.3 (6598.45-7907.33) and 9670.99 (8953.66-10,389.95).
The results reflect a possible worst-case scenario where the outbreak extends over all states of the U.S. and antivirals and vaccines are not administered. Our disease burden estimations are also likely to be somewhat high due to the fact that only dense urban regions covering approximately 3% of the geographic area and 81% of the population are used for simulating sample outbreaks. Outcomes from these simulations are extrapolated over the remaining 19% of the population spread sparsely over 97% of the area. Furthermore, the full extent of possible NPIs, if deployed, could also have lowered the disease burden estimates.
自2013年春季以来,甲型H7N9禽流感病毒在中国周期性出现,这加剧了人们对可能在人类中爆发大流行的担忧,尽管据信该病毒尚未在人际间传播。截至2017年6月,甲型H7N9禽流感已导致1533例实验室确诊的人类感染病例,造成592人死亡。本文的目的是在甲型H7N9病毒获得人际传播能力可能引发大流行的情况下,给出疾病负担估计(以感染发病率(IAR)和死亡人数衡量)。尽管这样的大流行可能会在全球范围内传播,但本文我们的重点是仅估计对美国的影响。
该方法首先使用数据聚类技术将美国的50个州划分为少数几个集群。此后,对于每个集群中选定的几个州,该方法采用基于主体的(AB)模型来模拟人类甲型H7N9禽流感大流行疫情。该模型使用人口统计学和流行病学数据。应用了一些选定的非药物干预(NPI)措施来减轻疫情。通过应用分层抽样中使用的方法合并各集群的结果来估计美国的疾病负担。
研究了两种可能的大流行情景,R分别为1.5和1.8。R = 1.5和1.8时,感染发病率及其95%置信区间(CI)估计分别为18.78%(17.3 - 20.27)和25.05%(23.11 - 26.99)。每10万人相应的死亡人数(95% CI)分别为7252.3(6598.45 - 7907.33)和9670.99(8953.66 - 10389.95)。
结果反映了一种可能的最坏情况,即疫情蔓延至美国所有州且未使用抗病毒药物和疫苗。由于仅使用了覆盖约3%地理区域和81%人口的密集城市地区来模拟样本疫情,我们的疾病负担估计可能也会偏高。这些模拟结果被外推到稀疏分布在97%区域的其余19%人口上。此外,如果部署了可能的非药物干预措施,其全部影响也可能降低疾病负担估计。