Departments of Psychology, Philosophy and Neuroscience, Center for Behavioral Neuroscience, Language Research Center, Georgia State University, Atlanta, GA, USA
Centre for Ecology and Conservation, College of Life and Environmental Sciences, University of Exeter, Cornwall Campus, Penryn TR10 9FE, UK.
Proc Biol Sci. 2017 Dec 20;284(1869). doi: 10.1098/rspb.2017.2146.
How special are humans? This question drives scholarly output across both the sciences and the humanities. Whereas some disciplines, and the humanities in particular, aim at gaining a better understanding of humans , most biologists ultimately aim to understand life in general. This raises the question of whether and when humans are acceptable, or even desirable, models of biological fundamentals. Especially for basic biological processes, non-human species are generally accepted as a relevant model to study topics for which studying humans is impractical, impossible, or ethically inadvisable, but the reverse is controversial: are humans 'too unique' to be informative with respect to biological fundamentals relevant to other species? Or are there areas where we share key components, or for which our very uniqueness serves to allow novel explorations? In this special feature, authors from disciplines including biology, psychology, anthropology, neuroscience and philosophy tackle this question. Their overall conclusion is a qualified yes: humans do tell us about biological fundamentals, in some contexts. We hope this special feature will spur a discussion that will lead to a more careful delineation of the similarities and the differences between humans and other species, and how these impact the study of biological fundamentals.
人类有何特别之处?这个问题推动了科学和人文领域的学术产出。虽然一些学科,尤其是人文科学,旨在更好地了解人类,但大多数生物学家最终的目标是理解一般的生命。这就提出了一个问题,即人类是否可以接受,甚至是否可取,作为生物学基本原理的模型。特别是对于基本的生物过程,非人类物种通常被认为是一个相关的模型,可以用来研究那些研究人类不切实际、不可能或不道德的话题,但反过来则存在争议:对于与其他物种相关的生物学基本原理,人类是否“过于独特”而无法提供信息?或者在某些领域,我们是否共享关键组成部分,或者我们的独特性是否有助于进行新的探索?在本期特刊中,来自生物学、心理学、人类学、神经科学和哲学等学科的作者探讨了这个问题。他们的总体结论是有条件的肯定:在某些情况下,人类确实可以让我们了解生物学的基本原理。我们希望本期特刊能够引发一场讨论,促使人们更仔细地区分人类和其他物种之间的相似之处和不同之处,以及这些相似之处和不同之处如何影响生物学基本原理的研究。