Akerman Jason Paul, Allard Christopher B, Tajzler Camilla, Kapoor Anil
McMaster Institute of Urology, McMaster University, Hamilton, ON, Canada.
Can Urol Assoc J. 2018 Feb;12(2):E53-E58. doi: 10.5489/cuaj.4631. Epub 2017 Dec 1.
This study serves as an update of prostate cancer screening practices among family physicians in Ontario, Canada. Since this population was first surveyed in 2010, the Canadian Task Force on Preventive Health Care (CTFPHC) and the United States Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) released recommendations against prostate cancer screening.
An online survey was developed through input from urologists and family practitioners. It was distributed via email to all members of the Ontario Medical Association's Section on General and Family practice (11 657 family physicians). A reminder email was sent at two weeks and the survey remained active for one month.
A total of 1880 family physicians completed surveys (response rate 16.1%). Overall, 80.4% offered prostate cancer screening compared to 91.7% when surveyed in 2010. Physicians new to practice (two years or less) were the most likely to not offer screening (24.6%). A combination of digital rectal exam (DRE) and prostate-specific antigen (PSA) remained the most common form of screening (58.3%). Following the release of the CTFPHC recommendations, 45.6% of respondents said they now screen fewer patients. Participants were less familiar with national urological society guidelines compared to task force recommendations. The majority (72.6%) of respondents feel PSA screening leads to overdiagnosis and treatment. Those surveyed remained split with respect to PSA utility.
Data suggest a decline in screening practices since 2010, with newer graduates less likely to offer screening. CFTPHC and USPSTF recommendations had the greatest impact on clinical practice. Those surveyed were divided with respect to PSA utility. Some additional considerations to PSA screening in the primary care setting, including patient-driven factors, were not captured by our concise survey.
本研究是对加拿大安大略省家庭医生前列腺癌筛查实践的一次更新。自2010年首次对该人群进行调查以来,加拿大预防保健特别工作组(CTFPHC)和美国预防服务工作组(USPSTF)发布了反对前列腺癌筛查的建议。
通过泌尿科医生和家庭医生的意见开发了一项在线调查。通过电子邮件将其分发给安大略医学协会普通和家庭实践科的所有成员(11657名家庭医生)。两周后发送了提醒邮件,调查持续了一个月。
共有1880名家庭医生完成了调查(回复率16.1%)。总体而言,80.4%的医生提供前列腺癌筛查,而2010年调查时这一比例为91.7%。新执业(两年或以下)的医生最有可能不提供筛查(24.6%)。直肠指检(DRE)和前列腺特异性抗原(PSA)联合检查仍然是最常见的筛查方式(58.3%)。CTFPHC建议发布后,45.6%的受访者表示他们现在筛查的患者减少了。与特别工作组的建议相比,参与者对国家泌尿外科学会指南的熟悉程度较低。大多数(72.6%)受访者认为PSA筛查会导致过度诊断和治疗。受访者在PSA的效用方面仍然存在分歧。
数据表明自2010年以来筛查实践有所下降,新毕业的医生提供筛查的可能性较小。CFTPHC和USPSTF的建议对临床实践产生了最大影响。受访者在PSA的效用方面存在分歧。我们简洁的调查未涵盖基层医疗环境中PSA筛查的一些其他考虑因素,包括患者驱动因素。