Bulliard Jean-Luc, Chiolero Arnaud
1Division of Chronic Diseases, Institute of social and preventive medicine (IUMSP), Lausanne University Hospital, Lausanne, Switzerland.
Observatoire valaisan de la santé (OVS), Sion, Switzerland.
Public Health Rev. 2015 Nov 5;36:8. doi: 10.1186/s40985-015-0012-1. eCollection 2015.
Overdiagnosis is the diagnosis of an abnormality that bears no substantial health hazard and no benefit for patients to be aware of. Resulting mainly from the use of increasingly sensitive screening and diagnostic tests, as well as broadened definitions of conditions requiring an intervention, overdiagnosis is a growing but still largely misunderstood public health issue. Fear of missing a diagnosis or of litigation, financial incentives or patient's need of reassurance are further causes of overdiagnosis. The main consequence of overdiagnosis is overtreatment. Treating an overdiagnosed condition bears no benefit but can cause harms and generates costs. Overtreatment also diverts health professionals from caring for those most severely ill. Recognition of overdiagnosis due to screening is challenging since it is rarely identifiable at the individual level and difficult to quantify precisely at the population level. Overdiagnosis exists even for screening of proven efficacy and efficiency. Measures to reduce overdiagnosis due to screening include heightened sensitization of health professionals and patients, active surveillance and deferred treatment until early signs of disease progression and prognosis estimation through biomarkers (including molecular) profiling. Targeted screening and balanced information on its risk and benefits would also help limit overdiagnosis. Research is needed to assess the public health burden and implications of overdiagnosis due to screening activity.
过度诊断是指对一种并无实质性健康危害且患者知晓后无益处的异常情况进行诊断。过度诊断主要源于使用越来越敏感的筛查和诊断测试,以及对需要干预的病症定义的拓宽,它是一个日益严重但仍在很大程度上被误解的公共卫生问题。害怕漏诊或面临诉讼、经济激励或患者需要安心等也是过度诊断的进一步原因。过度诊断的主要后果是过度治疗。治疗过度诊断出的病症没有益处,反而可能造成伤害并产生成本。过度治疗还会使医疗专业人员无法照顾那些病情最严重的患者。由于筛查导致的过度诊断难以识别,因为它在个体层面很少能被识别出来,在人群层面也难以精确量化。即使是对已证实具有疗效和效率的筛查,过度诊断也依然存在。减少因筛查导致的过度诊断的措施包括提高医疗专业人员和患者的认识、主动监测以及推迟治疗,直到疾病进展的早期迹象出现,并通过生物标志物(包括分子)分析进行预后评估。有针对性的筛查以及关于其风险和益处的平衡信息也将有助于限制过度诊断。需要开展研究来评估因筛查活动导致的过度诊断所带来的公共卫生负担和影响。