Ramkumar Vidya, John K R, Selvakumar K, Vanaja C S, Nagarajan Roopa, Hall James W
a Department of Speech, Language and Hearing Sciences , Sri Ramachandra University , Chennai , India.
b Department of Community Medicine , SRM University , Chengalpattu , India.
Int J Audiol. 2018 Jun;57(6):407-414. doi: 10.1080/14992027.2018.1442592. Epub 2018 Feb 28.
This study evaluated the cost and outcome of a community-based hearing screening programme in which village health workers (VHWs) screened children in their homes using a two-step DPOAE screening protocol. Children referred in a second screening underwent tele diagnostic ABR testing in a mobile tele-van using satellite connectivity or at local centre using broadband internet at the rural location.
Economic analysis was carried out to estimate cost incurred and outcome achieved for hearing screening, follow-up diagnostic assessment and identification of hearing loss. Two-way sensitivity analysis determined the most beneficial cost-outcome.
1335 children under 5 years of age underwent screening by VHWs.
Nineteen of the 22 children referred completed the tele diagnostic evaluation. Five children were identified with hearing loss. The cost-outcomes were better when using broadband internet for tele-diagnostics. The use of least expensive human resources and equipment yielded the lowest cost per child screened (Rs.1526; $23; €21). When follow-up expenses were thus maximised, the cost per child was reduced considerably for diagnostic hearing assessment (Rs.102,065; $1532; €1368) and for the cost per child identified (Rs.388,237; $5826; €5204).
Settings with constrained resources can benefit from a community-based programme integrated with tele diagnostics.
本研究评估了一项基于社区的听力筛查项目的成本和结果,该项目中乡村卫生工作者(VHWs)使用两步畸变产物耳声发射(DPOAE)筛查方案在儿童家中对其进行筛查。在二次筛查中被转诊的儿童在移动电视车内使用卫星连接进行远程诊断听性脑干反应(ABR)测试,或在农村地区的当地中心使用宽带互联网进行测试。
进行经济分析以估计听力筛查、后续诊断评估和听力损失识别所产生的成本和取得的结果。双向敏感性分析确定了最具效益的成本效益。
1335名5岁以下儿童接受了乡村卫生工作者的筛查。
22名被转诊儿童中有19名完成了远程诊断评估。5名儿童被确诊为听力损失。使用宽带互联网进行远程诊断时,成本效益更好。使用成本最低的人力资源和设备,每个接受筛查儿童的成本最低(1526卢比;23美元;21欧元)。当后续费用最大化时,诊断性听力评估的每个儿童成本(102,065卢比;1532美元;1368欧元)和每个确诊儿童的成本(388,237卢比;5826美元;5204欧元)大幅降低。
资源有限的地区可以从与远程诊断相结合的社区项目中受益。