Gheller Brandon Jf, Joy Phillip, Lordly Daphne
a Department of Applied Human Nutrition, Mount Saint Vincent University, Halifax, NS.
Can J Diet Pract Res. 2018 Jun 1;79(2):55-59. doi: 10.3148/cjdpr-2018-003. Epub 2018 Mar 15.
In Canada, dietitians serve a sex-diverse population despite the profession being predominately female (>95%). It is unknown why there are so few male dietitians. The objective of the present study was to explore the experience of the male dietitian, as a minority, in female-dominated dietetics.
Two semi-structured interviews were conducted, approximately 6 weeks apart, with Nova Scotian male dietitians. The interviews prompted participants to reflect on their experience of being a male dietitian. Interviews were analyzed using Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis.
Male dietitians with between 1 and 17 years of experience participated (n = 6). Participant experiences were expressed as 4 themes: (i) feelings of difference and otherness, (ii) adapting to the female-dominated culture, (iii) constructing a professional identity, and (iv) passion as the driver for success. A theoretical framework for understanding the male dietitian's experience was outlined.
The experience of the male dietitian is unique and is a consequence of training and practicing in a female-dominated space. The effect of adaptation and construction of a professional identity that is a response to female-dominated cultural norms is wide ranging and may be constraining for male practitioners thereby affecting their contributions to the field.
在加拿大,尽管营养师职业中女性占主导地位(超过95%),但营养师服务的人群性别多样。目前尚不清楚男性营养师为何如此之少。本研究的目的是探讨男性营养师作为少数群体在女性主导的营养学领域中的经历。
对新斯科舍省的男性营养师进行了两次半结构化访谈,间隔约6周。访谈促使参与者反思自己作为男性营养师的经历。采用解释现象学分析方法对访谈进行分析。
有1至17年工作经验的男性营养师参与了研究(n = 6)。参与者的经历表现为4个主题:(i)差异感和他者感;(ii)适应女性主导的文化;(iii)构建职业身份;(iv)激情是成功的驱动力。概述了一个理解男性营养师经历的理论框架。
男性营养师的经历是独特的,是在女性主导的环境中接受培训和实践的结果。适应和构建职业身份以回应女性主导的文化规范所产生的影响广泛,可能会限制男性从业者,从而影响他们对该领域的贡献。