Fransson S G, Sökjer H, Johansson K E, Tibbling L
Department of Diagnostic Radiology, University of Linköping, Sweden.
Acta Radiol. 1987 May-Jun;28(3):295-8.
It has been proposed that the high density of ordinary barium suspensions may complicate the radiologic diagnosis of gastro-oesophageal reflux. For this reason P-contrast was developed (Ferring AB); a contrast medium with the same density as water (1 g/cm3). A comparison of P-contrast and barium (Mixobar Ventrikel 400 mg/ml) was performed in 82 patients. All patients were examined with both contrast media and the findings were compared with those at reflux test at manometry, endoscopy and 24-hour pH monitoring. Another 40 patients and 15 symptom-free controls were examined with two different amounts of barium, 100 ml and 200 ml, to study if the radiologic diagnosis of reflux varied with the volume of contrast medium administered. P-contrast was found to have no advantages over barium for the diagnosis of gastro-oesophageal reflux. The outcome of the radiologic examination was not influenced by the different volumes of barium used.
有人提出,普通钡剂混悬液的高密度可能会使胃食管反流的放射学诊断复杂化。出于这个原因,研发了P造影剂(Ferring AB公司);一种密度与水相同(1克/立方厘米)的造影剂。对82例患者进行了P造影剂和钡剂(Mixobar Ventrikel 400毫克/毫升)的比较。所有患者均使用两种造影剂进行检查,并将检查结果与测压、内镜检查和24小时pH监测反流试验的结果进行比较。另外40例患者和15名无症状对照者使用两种不同量的钡剂(100毫升和200毫升)进行检查,以研究反流的放射学诊断是否随所用造影剂的量而变化。结果发现,在胃食管反流的诊断方面,P造影剂并不比钡剂有优势。放射学检查的结果不受所用钡剂不同量的影响。