Chen Bin, Shao Jian, Liu Kui, Cai Gaofeng, Jiang Zhenggang, Huang Yuru, Gu Hua, Jiang Jianmin
Zhejiang Provincial Center for Disease Control and Prevention, Hangzhou, China.
College of Computer Science, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou, China.
JMIR Public Health Surveill. 2018 Mar 29;4(1):e32. doi: 10.2196/publichealth.8198.
A hot topic on the relationship between a popular avian-origin food and avian influenza occurred on social media during the outbreak of the emerging avian influenza A (H7N9). The misinformation generated from this topic had caused great confusion and public concern.
Our goals were to analyze the trend and contents of the relevant posts during the outbreak. We also aimed to understand the characteristics of the misinformation and to provide suggestions to reduce public misconception on social media during the emerging disease outbreak.
The original microblog posts were collected from China's Sina Weibo and Tencent Weibo using a combination of keywords between April 1, 2013 and June 2, 2013. We analyzed the weekly and daily trend of the relevant posts. Content analyses were applied to categorize the posts into 4 types with unified sorting criteria. The posts' characteristics and geographic locations were also analyzed in each category. We conducted further analysis on the top 5 most popular misleading posts.
A total of 1680 original microblog posts on the topic were retrieved and 341 (20.30%) of these posts were categorized as misleading messages. The number of relevant posts had not increased much during the first 2 weeks but rose to a high level in the next 2 weeks after the sudden increase in number of reported cases at the beginning of week 3. The posts under "misleading messages" occurred and increased from the beginning of week 3, but their daily posting number decreased when the daily number of posts under "refuting messages" outnumbered them. The microbloggers of the misleading posts had the lowest mean rank of followers and previous posts, but their posts had a highest mean rank of posts. The proportion of "misleading messages" in places with no reported cases was significantly higher than that in the epidemic areas (23.6% vs 13.8%). The popular misleading posts appeared to be short and consisted of personal narratives, which were easily disseminated on social media.
Our findings suggested the importance of responding to common questions and misconceptions on social media platforms from the beginning of disease outbreaks. Authorities need to release clear and reliable information related to the popular topics early on. The microbloggers posting correct information should be empowered and their posts could be promoted to clarify false information. Equal importance should be attached to clarify misinformation in both the outbreak and nonoutbreak areas.
在新型甲型H7N9禽流感疫情爆发期间,社交媒体上出现了一个关于一种受欢迎的禽类来源食品与禽流感关系的热门话题。该话题产生的错误信息造成了极大的混乱和公众关注。
我们的目标是分析疫情爆发期间相关帖子的趋势和内容。我们还旨在了解错误信息的特征,并为在新兴疾病爆发期间减少社交媒体上公众的误解提供建议。
使用关键词组合从中国的新浪微博和腾讯微博收集2013年4月1日至2013年6月2日的原始微博帖子。我们分析了相关帖子的每周和每日趋势。应用内容分析法,按照统一的分类标准将帖子分为4类。还对每类帖子的特征和地理位置进行了分析。我们对最热门的5条误导性帖子进行了进一步分析。
共检索到1680条关于该话题的原始微博帖子,其中341条(20.30%)被归类为误导性信息。在前三周的前两周,相关帖子数量增长不多,但在第3周初报告病例数突然增加后的接下来两周内升至高位。“误导性信息”类帖子从第3周初开始出现并增加,但当“辟谣信息”类帖子的每日发布数量超过它们时,其每日发布数量下降。误导性帖子的博主拥有的粉丝平均排名和之前帖子的平均排名最低,但他们帖子的平均发布排名最高。在没有报告病例的地区,“误导性信息”的比例明显高于疫情地区(23.6%对13.8%)。热门的误导性帖子似乎篇幅较短,且包含个人叙述,很容易在社交媒体上传播。
我们的研究结果表明,在疾病爆发初期就应对社交媒体平台上的常见问题和误解非常重要。当局需要尽早发布与热门话题相关的清晰可靠信息。发布正确信息的博主应得到支持,他们的帖子可以得到推广以澄清错误信息。在疫情爆发地区和非疫情爆发地区澄清错误信息应同等重视。