Dellazizzo Laura, Potvin Stéphane, Phraxayavong Kingsada, Lalonde Pierre, Dumais Alexandre
Centre de recherche de l'Institut Universitaire en Santé Mentale de Montréal, Montreal, QC, Canada.
Department of Psychiatry and Addictology, Faculty of Medicine, Université de Montréal, Montreal, QC, Canada.
Front Psychiatry. 2018 Apr 16;9:131. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2018.00131. eCollection 2018.
Effective treatment strategies for schizophrenia remain very challenging and many treatment-resistant patients will suffer from persistent auditory verbal hallucinations (AVH). While clozapine is the gold-standard medication for this complex population, many will not respond to this molecule. For these ultra-resistant patients, limited options are available. Cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) is the most widely used psychological intervention, though it offers modest effects. With the interpersonal dimension of AVH being recognized, Avatar Therapy (AT), a novel experiential treatment enabling patients to create an avatar of their persecutor and allowing them to gain control over their symptoms, was developed and tested. Results have shown significant improvements in AVH symptomatology. This paper details a case report showcasing the beneficial results of AT for even the most severe and symptomatic cases of schizophrenia. Mr. Smith has been afflicted with the persistency of all his voices for almost 20 years. To our knowledge, this patient tried almost all possible treatments with little efficacy. This case highlights the difficulty of finding an adequate treatment for ultra-resistant patients. Mr. Smith first followed CBT before initiating AT. With AT, he significantly improved in a way that was not observed with any other intervention and these improvements remained afterward. The severity of his positive symptoms as well as his depressive symptoms diminished, and his most distressing persecutory voice disappeared. He was able to regain a life. The effects of AT went well beyond the patient, the morale of the entire family improved. This ultra-resistant case suggests that AT may be a promising intervention for refractory AVH in schizophrenia.
精神分裂症的有效治疗策略仍然极具挑战性,许多难治性患者会遭受持续性幻听(AVH)的困扰。虽然氯氮平是针对这一复杂群体的金标准药物,但许多患者对该药物并无反应。对于这些极端难治性患者,可用的选择有限。认知行为疗法(CBT)是使用最广泛的心理干预方法,不过其效果一般。随着幻听人际维度的被认可,替身疗法(AT)应运而生并经过了测试,这是一种新颖的体验式治疗方法,能让患者创建迫害者的替身,并让他们对自身症状获得控制。结果显示,幻听症状有显著改善。本文详细介绍了一例病例报告,展示了替身疗法对即使是最严重、症状最明显的精神分裂症病例也有有益效果。史密斯先生受所有幻听困扰近20年。据我们所知,该患者几乎尝试了所有可能的治疗方法,但效果甚微。这个病例凸显了为难治性患者找到合适治疗方法的困难。史密斯先生在开始接受替身疗法之前先接受了认知行为疗法。通过替身疗法,他有了显著改善,这是其他任何干预措施都未观察到的,而且这些改善一直持续。他的阳性症状以及抑郁症状的严重程度减轻了,最令他痛苦的迫害性幻听消失了。他能够重新过上正常生活。替身疗法的影响不仅限于患者本人,整个家庭的士气也得到了提升。这个极端难治性病例表明,替身疗法可能是治疗精神分裂症难治性幻听的一种有前景的干预措施。