Fotheringham Elspeth M, Craig Pippa, Tor Elina
School of Medicine, University of Notre Dame, Australia.
Int J Med Educ. 2018 May 23;9:137-144. doi: 10.5116/ijme.5aed.682f.
To explore the host experience on international medical electives at a selection of hospitals in low- and middle-income countries in Africa. Outcomes of the study may inform and improve the preparation of global health curriculum, pre-elective training and debriefing for international medical electives.
A descriptive phenomenological study was undertaken, involving semi-structured interviews with ten elective hosts at seven study sites in three African countries. Purposive convenience sampling augmented by snowballing was utilised to recruit study participants. The data were thematically analysed and interpreted with reflexivity to generate an accurate aggregate of the experience of participants in hosting international medical electives.
Six main themes emerged from the thematic analysis of interview data: international medical student contribution to host hospitals, host professional and personal fulfiment, barriers to student learning experience, international medical student preparedness, hope for reciprocity and barriers to cultural immersion and patient care.
Study participants described the experience of hosting international medical elective students as overwhelmingly positive. However, they highlighted issues such as barriers to students' learning experience and the lack of reciprocity between host and sending institutions as areas which could be addressed to optimize the experience for both hosts and international medical students. An understanding of the host experience provides stakeholders with a clearer idea of what is important in preparation, organisation and evaluation of the elective experience. This study provides the impetus for further research to examine the effectiveness of introducing appropriate pre-departure training and post-elective debriefing to students embarking on international medical electives.
探讨非洲低收入和中等收入国家部分医院接待国际医学选修生的东道主体验。该研究结果可为全球健康课程的准备、选修前培训以及国际医学选修生的汇报提供参考并加以改进。
开展一项描述性现象学研究,对三个非洲国家七个研究地点的十位选修生东道主进行半结构化访谈。采用立意便利抽样并辅以滚雪球抽样的方法招募研究参与者。对数据进行主题分析并通过反思性分析进行解读,以准确汇总东道主接待国际医学选修生的体验。
访谈数据的主题分析得出六个主要主题:国际医学学生对东道主医院的贡献、东道主的职业和个人成就感、学生学习体验的障碍、国际医学学生的准备情况、互惠的期望以及文化融入和患者护理的障碍。
研究参与者将接待国际医学选修生的体验描述为总体上是积极的。然而,他们强调了一些问题,如学生学习体验的障碍以及东道主与派遣机构之间缺乏互惠等,这些方面可以加以解决,以优化东道主和国际医学学生双方的体验。了解东道主体验能让利益相关者更清楚地了解在选修体验的准备、组织和评估中哪些方面很重要。本研究为进一步研究提供了动力,以检验对参加国际医学选修生的学生引入适当的出发前培训和选修后汇报的有效性。