Ling Steven, Jacobs Robert, Ponton Rhys, Slark Julia, Verstappen Antonia, Webster Craig S, Poole Phillippa
Faculty of Medical and Health Sciences, University of Auckland, New Zealand.
School of Optometry and Vision Science, University of Auckland, New Zealand.
J Prim Health Care. 2018 Mar;10(1):54-61. doi: 10.1071/HC17052.
INTRODUCTION In New Zealand (NZ), there are shortages of health professionals in rural areas and in primary care. AIM This study aims to examine the association of student debt levels of medical, nursing, pharmacy and optometry students with: (1) preferred geographical location of practice, specifically preference to work in urban vs. rural areas; and (2) preferred career specialties, specifically interest in primary health care. METHODS Medical, nursing, pharmacy and optometry students completed a questionnaire at graduation that included questions about levels of New Zealand Government Student Loan debt and preferences regarding location of practice and career specialty. In an additional survey, medical students were asked to self-rate the effect of financial factors on their career choices. RESULTS Debt patterns varied across programmes. Medical and pharmacy students with high debt were significantly more likely than students with low debt to prefer rural over urban practice (P = 0.003). There was no difference in level of interest in a primary care specialty by debt level for any programme. Medical students reported little influence of debt on career choice, although students with high debt levels were less concerned over career financial prospects than students with lower levels of debt. DISCUSSION Current levels of student debt do not deter students from planning a career in rural or primary care settings. Somewhat surprisingly, higher levels of debt are associated with greater rural practice intentions for medical and pharmacy students, although the underlying reasons are uncertain.
引言 在新西兰(NZ),农村地区和初级保健领域存在卫生专业人员短缺的情况。目的 本研究旨在探讨医学、护理、药学和验光专业学生的学生债务水平与以下方面的关联:(1)首选的执业地理位置,特别是在城市与农村地区工作的偏好;(2)首选的职业专业,特别是对初级卫生保健的兴趣。方法 医学、护理、药学和验光专业学生在毕业时完成了一份问卷,其中包括有关新西兰政府学生贷款债务水平以及执业地点和职业专业偏好的问题。在另一项调查中,医学生被要求对财务因素对其职业选择的影响进行自我评估。结果 不同专业的债务模式各不相同。债务高的医学和药学专业学生比债务低的学生更倾向于选择农村而非城市执业(P = 0.003)。任何专业中,按债务水平划分,对初级保健专业的兴趣程度没有差异。医学生报告称债务对职业选择影响不大,尽管债务水平高的学生比债务水平低的学生对职业财务前景的担忧更少。讨论 当前的学生债务水平并未阻止学生规划在农村或初级保健环境中的职业。有点令人惊讶的是,较高的债务水平与医学和药学专业学生更大的农村执业意愿相关,尽管其潜在原因尚不确定。