Bess Michael
Vanderbilt University, Nashville, Tennessee, USA.
J Med Philos. 2018 Sep 5;43(5):585-612. doi: 10.1093/jmp/jhy018.
Over the coming century, the accelerating advance of bioenhancement technologies, robotics, and artificial intelligence (AI) may significantly broaden the qualitative range of sentient and intelligent beings. This article proposes a taxonomy of such beings, ranging from modified animals to bioenhanced humans to advanced forms of robots and AI. It divides these diverse beings into three moral and legal categories-animals, persons, and presumed persons-describing the moral attributes and legal rights of each category. In so doing, the article sets forth a framework for extending the concept of personhood well beyond its current boundaries, assigning moral standing to a variety of biological and nonbiological beings. The author concludes that six of the eight subgroups of such beings deserve to be treated as persons or as if they were persons, with full consideration for their presumed interests, rights, obligations, and capabilities for ethically significant agency and patiency.
在接下来的一个世纪里,生物增强技术、机器人技术和人工智能(AI)的加速发展可能会显著拓宽有感知力和智能的生物的质量范围。本文提出了这样一类生物的分类法,从经过改造的动物到生物增强的人类,再到先进形式的机器人和人工智能。它将这些不同的生物分为三个道德和法律类别——动物、人以及准人,描述了每个类别的道德属性和法律权利。通过这样做,本文提出了一个框架,将人格概念扩展到远远超出其当前界限的范围,赋予各种生物和非生物以道德地位。作者得出结论,这类生物的八个子群体中的六个应该被视为人或被当作人来对待,要充分考虑到它们假定的利益、权利、义务以及在伦理上具有重要意义的行为能力和承受能力。