Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Radboud University Medical Center, Geert Grooteplein Zuid 10, 6523, GA, Nijmegen, the Netherlands.
Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Amsterdam University Medical Centers, Amsterdam, the Netherlands.
BMC Pregnancy Childbirth. 2018 Sep 20;18(1):380. doi: 10.1186/s12884-018-1973-0.
Late- and postterm pregnancy are associated with adverse perinatal outcomes, like perinatal death. We evaluated causes of death and substandard care factors (SSFs) in term and postterm perinatal death.
We used data from the Perinatal Audit Registry of the Netherlands (PARS). Women with a term perinatal death registered in PARS were stratified by gestational age into early-/full-term (37.0-40.6) and late-/postterm (≥41.0 weeks) death. Cause of death and SSFs ≥41 weeks were scored and classified by the local perinatal audit teams.
During 2010-2012, 947/479,097 (0.21%) term deaths occurred, from which 707 cases (75%) were registered and could be used for analyses. Five hundred ninety-eight early-/full-term and 109 late-/postterm audited deaths were registered in the PARS database. Of all audited cases of perinatal death in the PARS database, 55.2% in the early-/fullterm group occurred antepartum compared to 42.2% in the late-/postterm group, while intrapartum death occurred in 7.2% in the early-/full-term group compared to 19.3% in the late-/postterm group in the audited cases from the PARS database. According to the local perinatal audit, the most relevant causes of perinatal death ≥41 weeks were antepartum asphyxia (7.3%), intrapartum asphyxia (9.2%), neonatal asphyxia (10.1%) and placental insufficiency (10.1%). In the group with perinatal death ≥41 weeks there was ≥1SSF identified in 68.8%. The most frequent SSFs concerned inadequate cardiotocography (CTG) evaluation and/or classification (10.1%), incomplete registration or documentation in medical files (4.6%) or inadequate action on decreased foetal movements (4.6%).
In the Netherlands Perinatal Audit Registry, stillbirth occurred relatively less often antepartum and more often intrapartum in pregnancies ≥41 weeks compared to pregnancies at 37.0-40.6 weeks in the audited cases from the PARS database. Foetal, intrapartum and neonatal asphyxia were identified more frequently as cause of death in pregnancies ≥41 weeks. The most identified SSFs related to death in pregnancies ≥41 weeks concerned inadequate CTG monitoring (evaluation, classification, registration or documentation) and inadequate action on decreased foetal movements.
晚期和过期妊娠与围产儿不良结局相关,如围产儿死亡。我们评估了足月和过期妊娠围产儿死亡的死因和不符合标准的护理因素(SSFs)。
我们使用了荷兰围产儿审计登记处(PARS)的数据。将 PARS 登记的足月围产儿死亡的女性按胎龄分为早期/足月(37.0-40.6)和晚期/过期(≥41.0 周)死亡。由当地围产儿审计团队对死因和 SSFs(≥41 周)进行评分和分类。
2010-2012 年期间,479097 例足月妊娠中发生了 947 例(0.21%)围产儿死亡,其中 707 例(75%)病例被登记并可用于分析。PARS 数据库中登记了 598 例早期/足月和 109 例晚期/过期围产儿死亡。在 PARS 数据库中所有经审核的围产儿死亡病例中,55.2%的早期/足月组发生在产前,而晚期/过期组为 42.2%,而在经审核的 PARS 数据库中,早期/足月组的产时死亡为 7.2%,而晚期/过期组为 19.3%。根据当地围产儿审计,≥41 周围产儿死亡的最相关原因是产前窒息(7.3%)、产时窒息(9.2%)、新生儿窒息(10.1%)和胎盘功能不全(10.1%)。在≥41 周围产儿死亡组中,有≥1 项 SSFs 被确定,占 68.8%。最常见的 SSFs 涉及不充分的胎心监护(CTG)评估和/或分类(10.1%)、医疗记录中不完整的登记或文件记录(4.6%)或对胎动减少的不充分处理(4.6%)。
在荷兰围产儿审计登记处,与 PARS 数据库中审核的 37.0-40.6 周妊娠相比,≥41 周妊娠的死产较少发生在产前,更多发生在产时。在≥41 周妊娠中,胎儿、产时和新生儿窒息更常被确定为死亡原因。在≥41 周妊娠中,与死亡相关的最常见的 SSFs 涉及不充分的 CTG 监测(评估、分类、登记或记录)和对胎动减少的不充分处理。