Vandist Katleen, Storms Gert, Van den Bussche Eva
Department of Psychology, Vrije Universiteit Brussel, Pleinlaan 2, 1050, Brussels, Belgium.
Department of Experimental Psychology, KU Leuven, Leuven, Belgium.
Atten Percept Psychophys. 2019 Jan;81(1):137-157. doi: 10.3758/s13414-018-1595-7.
In the human category of learning, learning is studied in a supervised, an unsupervised, or a semisupervised way. The rare human semisupervised category of learning studies all focus on early learning. However, the impact of the semisupervised category learning late in learning, when automaticity develops, is unknown. Therefore, in Experiment 1, all participants were first trained on the information-integration category structure for 2 days until they reached an expert level. Afterwards, half of the participants learned in a supervised way and the other half in a semisupervised way over two successive days. Both groups received an equal number of feedback trials. Finally, all participants took part in a test day where they were asked to respond as quickly as possible. Participants were significantly faster on this test in the semisupervised group than in the supervised group. This difference was not found on day 2, implying that the no-feedback trials in the semisupervised condition facilitated automaticity. Experiment 2 was designed to test whether the higher number of trials in the semisupervised condition of Experiment 1 caused the faster response times. We therefore created an almost supervised condition where participants almost always received feedback (95%) and an almost unsupervised condition where participants almost never received feedback (5%). All conditions now contained an equal number of trials to the semisupervised condition of Experiment 1. The results show that receiving feedback almost always or almost never led to slower response times than the semisupervised condition of Experiment 1. This confirms the advantage of semisupervised learning late in learning.
在人类学习范畴中,学习是以监督、无监督或半监督方式进行研究的。罕见的人类半监督学习范畴研究均聚焦于早期学习。然而,在学习后期,即自动化形成时,半监督范畴学习的影响尚不清楚。因此,在实验1中,所有参与者首先在信息整合范畴结构上训练2天,直至达到专家水平。之后,一半参与者以监督方式学习,另一半在接下来的两天里以半监督方式学习。两组接受的反馈试验数量相等。最后,所有参与者参加一个测试日,要求他们尽快做出反应。半监督组的参与者在此次测试中的反应明显比监督组更快。这种差异在第2天未发现,这意味着半监督条件下的无反馈试验促进了自动化。实验2旨在测试实验1半监督条件下更多的试验次数是否导致了更快的反应时间。因此,我们创建了一个几乎是监督的条件,即参与者几乎总是收到反馈(95%),以及一个几乎是无监督的条件,即参与者几乎从未收到反馈(5%)。现在所有条件下的试验次数与实验1的半监督条件相等。结果表明,几乎总是收到反馈或几乎从未收到反馈导致的反应时间比实验1的半监督条件更慢。这证实了学习后期半监督学习的优势。