Altman Carmit, Goldstein Tamara, Armon-Lotem Sharon
School of Education at Bar Ilan University, Ramat Gan, Israel.
Department of English Literature and Linguistic, Gonda Multidisciplinary Brain Research Center, Bar Ilan University, Ramat Gan, Israel.
Front Psychol. 2018 Oct 23;9:1953. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2018.01953. eCollection 2018.
Awareness of language structure has been studied in bilinguals, but there is limited research on how language dominance is related to metalinguistic awareness, and whether metalinguistic awareness predicts vocabulary size. The present study aims to explore the role of language dominance in the relation between vocabulary size in both languages of bilingual children and metalinguistic awareness in the societal language. It evaluates the impact of two metalinguistic awareness abilities, morphological and lexical awareness, on receptive and expressive vocabulary size. This is of special interest since most studies focus on the impact of exposure on vocabulary size but very few explore the impact of the interaction between metalinguistic awareness and dominance. 5-6-year-old preschool children with typical language development participated in the study: 15 Russian-Hebrew bilingual children dominant in the societal language (SL) Hebrew, 21 Russian-Hebrew bilingual children dominant in the Heritage language (HL) Russian and 32 monolingual children. Dominance was determined by relative proficiency, based on standardized tests in the two languages. Tasks of morphological and lexical awareness were administered in SL-Hebrew, along with measures of receptive and expressive vocabulary size in both languages. Vocabulary size in SL-Hebrew was significantly higher for SL-dominant bilinguals (who performed like monolinguals) than for HL-dominant bilinguals, while HL-Russian vocabulary size was higher for HL-dominant bilinguals than for SL-dominant bilinguals. A hierarchical regression analyzing the relationship between vocabulary size and metalinguistic awareness showed that dominance, lexical metalinguistic awareness and the interaction between the two were predictors of both receptive and expressive vocabulary size. Morphological metalinguistic awareness was not a predictor of vocabulary size. The relationship between lexical awareness and SL-vocabulary size was limited to the HL-dominant group. HL-dominant bilinguals relied on lexical metalinguistic awareness, measured by fast mapping abilities, that is, the abilities to acquire new words, in expanding their vocabulary size, whereas SL-dominant bilinguals and monolinguals did not. This difference reflects the milestones of lexical acquisition the different groups have reached. These findings show that metalinguistic awareness should also be taken into consideration when evaluating the variables that influence vocabulary size among bilinguals though different ways in different dominance groups.
双语者的语言结构意识已得到研究,但关于语言优势与元语言意识之间的关系,以及元语言意识是否能预测词汇量的研究却很有限。本研究旨在探讨语言优势在双语儿童两种语言的词汇量与社会语言中的元语言意识之间的关系中所起的作用。它评估了两种元语言意识能力,即形态意识和词汇意识,对接受性和表达性词汇量的影响。这一点特别值得关注,因为大多数研究关注的是接触对词汇量的影响,而很少探讨元语言意识与语言优势之间相互作用的影响。5至6岁语言发育正常的学龄前儿童参与了这项研究:15名以社会语言(SL)希伯来语为主的俄语-希伯来语双语儿童,21名以传承语言(HL)俄语为主的俄语-希伯来语双语儿童,以及32名单语儿童。语言优势是根据两种语言的标准化测试中的相对熟练程度来确定的。形态意识和词汇意识任务用SL-希伯来语进行,同时还测量了两种语言的接受性和表达性词汇量。以SL为主的双语者(其表现与单语者相似)在SL-希伯来语中的词汇量显著高于以HL为主的双语者,而以HL为主的双语者在HL-俄语中的词汇量高于以SL为主的双语者。一项分析词汇量与元语言意识之间关系的分层回归表明,语言优势、词汇元语言意识以及两者之间的相互作用是接受性和表达性词汇量的预测因素。形态元语言意识不是词汇量的预测因素。词汇意识与SL-词汇量之间的关系仅限于以HL为主的群体。以HL为主的双语者依靠通过快速映射能力测量的词汇元语言意识,即获取新单词的能力,来扩大他们的词汇量,而以SL为主的双语者和单语者则不然。这种差异反映了不同群体在词汇习得方面所达到的里程碑。这些发现表明,在评估影响双语者词汇量的变量时,尽管不同优势群体的方式不同,但元语言意识也应被考虑在内。