Department of Health Services Research, CAPHRI School for Public Health and Primary Care, Faculty of Health Medicine and Lifesciences, Maastricht University, Maastricht, the Netherlands.
Department of Health Services Research, CAPHRI School for Public Health and Primary Care, Faculty of Health Medicine and Lifesciences, Maastricht University, Maastricht, the Netherlands.
J Am Med Dir Assoc. 2019 Mar;20(3):268-272. doi: 10.1016/j.jamda.2018.12.001. Epub 2019 Feb 1.
To examine family caregivers' experiences with end-of-life care for nursing home residents with dementia and associations with the residents dying peacefully.
A secondary data analysis of family caregiver data collected in the observational Dutch End of Life in Dementia (DEOLD) study between 2007 and 2010.
Data were collected at 34 Dutch nursing homes (2799 beds) representing the nation. We included 252 reports from bereaved family members of nursing home residents with dementia.
The primary outcome was dying peacefully, assessed by family members using an item from the Quality of Dying in Long-term Care instrument. Unpleasant experiences with end-of-life care were investigated using open-ended questions. Overall satisfaction with end-of-life care was assessed with the End-of-Life Satisfaction With Care (EOLD-SWC) scale, and families' appraisal of decision making was measured with the Decision Satisfaction Inventory. Associations were investigated with multilevel linear regression analyses using generalized estimating equations.
Families' reports of unpleasant experiences translated into 2 themes: neglect and lack of respect. Neglect involved facing inaccessibility, disinterest, or discontinuity of relations, and negligence in tailored care and information. Lack of respect involved perceptions of being purposefully disregarded, an insensitive approach towards resident and family, noncompliance with agreements, and violations of privacy. Unpleasant experiences with end-of-life care were negatively associated with families' perceptions of the resident dying peacefully. Families' assessment of their relative dying peacefully was positively associated with satisfaction with end-of-life care and decision making.
CONCLUSIONS/IMPLICATIONS: Families' reports of unpleasant experiences with end-of-life care may inform practice to improve perceived quality of dying of their loved ones. Humane and compassionate care and attention from physicians and other staff for resident and family may facilitate recollections of a peaceful death.
调查痴呆症养老院患者临终护理中家庭照顾者的经历及其与患者平静死亡的关联。
对 2007 年至 2010 年期间在荷兰观察性痴呆症临终研究(DEOLD)中收集的家庭护理员数据进行二次数据分析。
数据来自代表全国的 34 家荷兰养老院(2799 张床位)。我们纳入了 252 份来自痴呆症养老院患者丧亲家庭的报告。
主要结局是家庭成员使用长期护理临终质量量表中的一个项目评估的平静死亡。通过开放式问题调查临终护理中不愉快的经历。使用临终关怀满意度量表(EOLD-SWC)评估总体临终关怀满意度,使用决策满意度量表评估家庭对决策的评估。使用广义估计方程的多水平线性回归分析调查关联。
家庭报告的不愉快经历可归纳为 2 个主题:忽视和缺乏尊重。忽视涉及难以获得、不感兴趣或关系不连续,以及定制护理和信息方面的疏忽。缺乏尊重涉及对被故意忽视、对患者和家庭的冷漠态度、不遵守协议和侵犯隐私的看法。临终护理中不愉快的经历与家庭对患者平静死亡的看法呈负相关。家庭对其亲人平静死亡的评估与对临终关怀和决策的满意度呈正相关。
结论/意义:家庭报告的临终护理中不愉快的经历可能为改善其亲人临终质量提供实践信息。医生和其他工作人员对患者和家庭的人道和富有同情心的关怀和关注可能有助于回忆起平静的死亡。