Centre for Women's Mental Health, Division of Psychology and Mental Health, School of Health Sciences, Faculty of Biology, Medicine and Health, University of Manchester, Manchester Academic Health Science Centre, Manchester, UK.
Greater Manchester Mental Health NHS Foundation Trust, Prestwich, UK.
BMJ Open. 2019 Jan 17;9(1):e021891. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2018-021891.
Self-harm in prison is a major public health concern. Less than 5% of UK prisoners are women, but they carry out more than a fifth of prison self-harm. Scars resulting from self-harm can be traumatising and stigmatising, yet there has been little focus on recovery of women prisoners with self-harm scarring. Medical skin camouflage (MSC) clinics treat individuals with disfiguring skin conditions, with evidence of improved well-being, self-esteem and social interactions. Only one community study has piloted the use of MSC for self-harm scarring.
We describe an acceptability and feasibility pilot randomised controlled trial; the first to examine MSC for women prisoners who self-harm. We aim to randomise 20-25 women prisoners to a 6-week MSC intervention and 20-25 to a waitlist control (to receive the MSC after the study period). We aim to train at least 6-10 long-term prisoners with personal experience of self-harm to deliver the intervention. Before and after intervention, we will pilot collection of women-centred outcomes, including quality of life, well-being and self-esteem. We will pilot collection of self-harm incidents during the intervention, resources used to manage/treat self-harm and follow-up of women at 12 weeks from baseline. Data on recruitment, retention and dropout will be recorded. We aim for the acceptability of the intervention to prison staff and women prisoners to be explored in qualitative interviews and focus groups.
Ethical approval for COVER has been granted by the North East-York Research Ethics Committee (REC) for phases 1 and 2 (reference: 16/NE/0030) and West of Scotland REC 3 for phases 3 and 4 (reference: 16/WS/0155). Informed consent will be the primary consideration; it will be made clear that participation will have no effect on life in prison or eligibility for parole. Due to the nature of the study, disclosures of serious self-harm may need to be reported to prison officials. We aim for findings to be disseminated via events at the study prison, presentations at national/international conferences, journal publications, prison governor meetings and university/National Health Service trust communications.
NCT02638974; Pre-results.
监狱中的自残行为是一个主要的公共卫生问题。英国囚犯中女性不到 5%,但她们实施的自残行为却超过了五分之一。自残造成的伤疤可能会令人痛苦和感到耻辱,然而,对于有自残伤疤的女性囚犯的康复问题关注甚少。医学皮肤伪装(MSC)诊所治疗有毁容性皮肤状况的个体,有证据表明其改善了幸福感、自尊心和社交互动。仅有一项社区研究曾试用 MSC 治疗自残伤疤。
我们描述了一项可接受性和可行性试点随机对照试验;这是第一项研究 MSC 对自残的女性囚犯的效果。我们的目标是将 20-25 名女性囚犯随机分配到 6 周的 MSC 干预组和 20-25 名等待对照组(在研究期间接受 MSC)。我们的目标是培训至少 6-10 名有自残个人经验的长期囚犯来提供干预。在干预前后,我们将试点收集以女性为中心的结果,包括生活质量、幸福感和自尊心。我们将试点收集干预期间的自残事件、用于管理/治疗自残的资源以及从基线开始 12 周后的女性随访情况。将记录招募、保留和流失的数据。我们旨在通过定性访谈和焦点小组探索干预措施对监狱工作人员和女性囚犯的可接受性。
COVER 已获得东北-约克研究伦理委员会(REC)第 1 阶段和第 2 阶段(参考号:16/NE/0030)和苏格兰西部 REC 第 3 阶段和第 4 阶段(参考号:16/WS/0155)的批准。知情同意将是主要考虑因素;将明确表示,参与不会对监狱生活或获得假释产生影响。由于研究的性质,可能需要向监狱官员报告严重自残的披露。我们的目标是通过在研究监狱举行活动、在国家/国际会议上发表演讲、发表期刊文章、举行监狱长会议和大学/国民保健制度信托机构沟通等方式传播研究结果。
NCT02638974;预结果。