Department of Neurology, St Vincent's Hospital Melbourne, Victoria, Australia.
The Royal Melbourne Hospital, Parkville, Australia.
Int J Stroke. 2020 Jun;15(4):438-453. doi: 10.1177/1747493019830582. Epub 2019 Feb 20.
After an initial stroke, the risk of recurrent stroke is high. Models that implement best-practice recommendations for risk factor management in stroke survivors to prevent stroke recurrence remain elusive. We examined a model which focuses on vascular risk factor management to prevent stroke recurrence in survivors returning to their primary care physicians. This model is coordinated from the stroke unit, integrates specialist stroke services with primary care physicians, and directly involves patients and carers in risk factor management. It is underpinned by the shared care principle in which there is joint participation of specialists as well as primary care physicians in a planned, integrated delivery of care with ongoing involvement of patients and carers, a structure which encourages implementation of best-practice recommendations as well as transferability and sustainability. We hypothesized that an integrated, multimodal intervention based on a shared-care model which supports joint participation of stroke specialists and primary care physicians would improve the implementation of best-practice recommendations for risk factor management in stroke survivors returning to the community.
We undertook a double-blind randomized controlled trial, testing the model in three Australian cities using stroke survivors admitted to stroke units and discharged from hospital to return to their primary care physicians. The model was a shared care, multifaceted integrated program which included bidirectional feedback between general practitioner and specialist unit, education, and engagement of patient and carer in self-management with ongoing input from a multidisciplinary team. The primary endpoint was improvement or abolition of risk factors such as raised blood pressure, diabetes, hyperlipidemia, the modification of adverse life-style factors such as lack of exercise, smoking and alcohol abuse and adherence to preventive medication at one year. Intermediate measurement points were scheduled at three monthly intervals. Analysis was by intention to treat, evaluated by covariance or a linear model adjusting for confounding factors or variance of base-line risk factors. The study was registered as ACTRN = 1261100026498.
The study population was as follows: intervention ( = 112), control ( = 137). At baseline, there was no statistical difference between the groups for any variable. At the 12-month evaluation, there was a significant decrease in systolic blood pressure from baseline in the intervention group of 5.2 mmHg ( < 0.01). This change was not observed in the control group ( = 0.29). Moreover, at 12 months the mean systolic blood pressure in the intervention group was 129.4 mmHg (SD 14.7), a result which was not obtained in controls. Fasting total cholesterol as well as triglycerides was reduced significantly in the intervention group (both < 0.01) but this was not the case in the control group ( = 0.11 and = 0.27, respectively). At 12 months, there was no change in BMI in the intervention group but there was a significant increase in BMI ( = 0.02) in the control group. At 12 months in the intervention group, the mean distance walked with ease compared to the baseline measurements was increased by a mean distance of 600 m while in the control group the distance walked with ease was reduced compared to that measured at baseline. At 12 months, the Barthel index in the intervention group demonstrated improved function ( = 0.01), but no change was observed in controls. At 12 months in the intervention group, there was a significant decrease in number of standard alcoholic drinks consumed per week compared to the baseline ( = 0.04). This was not observed in the control group ( = 0.34).
In stroke survivors, the ICARUSS (Integrated Care for the Reduction of Secondary Stroke) model is superior to usual care with respect to best-practice recommendations for traditional risk factors as well as behavioral and functional outcomes.
初次中风后,再次中风的风险很高。目前仍缺乏能实施最佳中风幸存者风险因素管理建议以预防中风复发的模型。我们研究了一种专注于血管风险因素管理的模型,以预防返回初级保健医生的中风幸存者中风复发。该模型由中风病房协调,整合了专科中风服务与初级保健医生,并直接让患者和照顾者参与风险因素管理。它以共同照护原则为基础,在该原则下,专家和初级保健医生共同参与有计划、整合的护理提供,同时患者和照顾者持续参与,这一结构鼓励实施最佳实践建议以及转移和可持续性。我们假设,基于支持中风专家和初级保健医生共同参与的共同照护模式的综合、多模式干预措施,将改善返回社区的中风幸存者的风险因素管理最佳实践建议的实施。
我们进行了一项双盲随机对照试验,在澳大利亚三个城市使用中风病房收治并从医院出院返回初级保健医生的中风幸存者进行了模型测试。该模型是一种共同照护、多方面的综合方案,包括全科医生和专科病房之间的双向反馈、教育以及患者和照顾者自我管理的参与,同时由多学科团队提供持续投入。主要终点是改善或消除血压升高、糖尿病、血脂异常等风险因素,改变缺乏运动、吸烟和酗酒等不良生活方式因素,并在一年时坚持预防用药。中间测量点在每三个月进行一次。分析采用意向治疗,通过协方差或线性模型进行评估,调整混杂因素或基线风险因素的方差。该研究在澳大利亚临床试验注册中心注册,编号为 ACTRN = 1261100026498。
研究人群如下:干预组( = 112),对照组( = 137)。在基线时,两组之间在任何变量上均无统计学差异。在 12 个月评估时,干预组的收缩压从基线下降了 5.2mmHg( < 0.01)。对照组( = 0.29)没有观察到这种变化。此外,在 12 个月时,干预组的平均收缩压为 129.4mmHg(SD 14.7),对照组未达到这一结果。干预组的空腹总胆固醇和甘油三酯均显著降低(均 < 0.01),但对照组无此情况(分别为 = 0.11 和 = 0.27)。在 12 个月时,干预组的体重指数没有变化,但对照组的体重指数显著增加( = 0.02)。在干预组中,与基线测量相比,12 个月时轻松行走的平均距离增加了 600m,而对照组的轻松行走距离则减少。在 12 个月时,干预组的巴氏量表功能显示出改善( = 0.01),但对照组无此变化。在干预组中,与基线相比,每周标准饮酒量显著减少( = 0.04),对照组无此变化( = 0.34)。
在中风幸存者中,与常规护理相比,ICARUSS(降低二级中风的综合护理)模型在传统风险因素以及行为和功能结果方面更具优势。