Markelz Ana Elizabeth, Barsoumian Alice, Yun Heather
Brooke Army Medical Center, 3551 Roger Brooke Drive, JBSA, Fort Sam Houston, TX.
Mil Med. 2019 Oct 1;184(9-10):509-514. doi: 10.1093/milmed/usz006.
There are many unique aspects to the practice of military Infectious Diseases (ID). San Antonio Uniformed Services Health Consortium Infectious Disease (ID) Fellowship is a combined Army and Air Force active duty program. Program leadership thought ID military unique curriculum (MUC) was well integrated into the program. We sought to verify this assumption to guide the decision to formalize the ID MUC. This study describes our strategy for the refinement and implementation of ID specific MUC, assesses the fellow and faculty response to these changes, and provides an example for other programs to follow.
We identified important ID areas through lessons learned from personal military experience, data from the ID Army Knowledge Online e-mail consult service, input from military ID physicians, and the Army and Air Force ID consultants to the Surgeons General. The consultants provided feedback on perceived gaps, appropriateness, and strategy. Due to restrictions in available curricular time, we devised a three-pronged strategy for revision: adapt current curricular practices to include MUC content, develop new learning activities targeted at the key content area, and sustain existing, effective MUC experiences.Learners were assessed by multiple choice question correct answer rate, performance during the simulation exercise, and burn rotation evaluation. Data on correct answer rate were analyzed according to level of training by using Mann-Whitney U test. Program assessment was conducted through anonymous feedback at midyear and end of year program evaluations.
Twelve military unique ID content areas were identified. Diseases of pandemic potential and blood borne pathogen management were added after consultant input. Five experiences were adapted to include military content: core and noon conference series, simulation exercises, multiple choice quizzes, and infection control essay questions. A burn intensive care unit (ICU) rotation, Transport Isolation System exercise, and tour of trainee health facilities were the new learning activities introduced. The formal tropical medicine course, infection prevention in the deployed environment course, research opportunities and participation in trainee health outbreak investigations were sustained activities. Ten fellows participated in the military-unique spaced-education multiple-choice question series. Twenty-seven questions were attempted 814 times. 50.37% of questions were answered correctly the first time, increasing to 100% correct by the end of the activity. No difference was seen in the initial correct answer rate between the four senior fellows (median 55% [IQR 49.75, 63.25]) and the six first-year fellows (median 44% [IQR 39.25, 53]) (p = 0.114). Six fellows participated in the simulated deployment scenario. No failure of material synthesis was noted during the simulation exercise and all of the fellows satisfied the stated objectives. One fellow successfully completed the piloted burn ICU rotation. Fellows and faculty reported high satisfaction with the new curriculum.
Military GME programs are required by congress to address the unique aspects of military medicine. Senior fellow knowledge using the spaced interval multiple-choice quizzes did not differ from junior fellow rate, supporting our concern that the ID MUC needed to be enhanced. Enhancement of the MUC experience can be accomplished with minimal increases to curricular and faculty time.
军事传染病(ID)的实践有许多独特之处。圣安东尼奥联合军种卫生联盟传染病(ID)奖学金项目是陆军和空军现役联合项目。项目领导层认为ID军事独特课程(MUC)已很好地融入该项目。我们试图验证这一假设,以指导将ID MUC正式化的决策。本研究描述了我们完善和实施ID特定MUC的策略,评估了学员和教员对这些变化的反应,并为其他项目提供了可借鉴的范例。
我们通过个人军事经验中的经验教训、ID陆军知识在线电子邮件咨询服务的数据、军事ID医生的意见以及陆军和空军向军医局局长提供的ID顾问意见,确定了重要的ID领域。顾问们就感知到的差距、适当性和策略提供了反馈。由于课程时间有限,我们制定了三管齐下的修订策略:调整当前课程实践以纳入MUC内容,针对关键内容领域开展新的学习活动,并维持现有的有效MUC经验。通过多项选择题正确答案率、模拟演练中的表现以及烧伤轮转评估对学员进行评估。根据培训水平,使用曼-惠特尼U检验分析正确答案率数据。通过年中及年末项目评估中的匿名反馈进行项目评估。
确定了12个军事独特的ID内容领域。经顾问建议后增加了具有大流行潜力的疾病和血源性病原体管理内容。对五项活动进行了调整以纳入军事内容:核心和午间会议系列、模拟演练、多项选择题测验以及感染控制论述题。引入了烧伤重症监护病房(ICU)轮转、运输隔离系统演练以及学员健康设施参观等新的学习活动。正式的热带医学课程、部署环境中的感染预防课程、研究机会以及参与学员健康疫情调查等是持续开展的活动。10名学员参加了军事独特的间隔式教育多项选择题系列。共尝试了27道题,答题814次。首次答题时50.37%的问题回答正确,活动结束时正确率提高到100%。四名高年级学员(中位数55%[四分位距49.75, 63.25])和六名一年级学员(中位数44%[四分位距39.25, 53])的初始正确答案率没有差异(p = 0.114)。六名学员参加了模拟部署场景演练。模拟演练期间未发现材料综合方面的失误,所有学员均达到既定目标。一名学员成功完成了试点烧伤ICU轮转。学员和教员对新课程表示高度满意。
国会要求军事毕业后医学教育(GME)项目解决军事医学的独特方面。使用间隔式多项选择题测验时,高年级学员知识水平与低年级学员没有差异,这支持了我们对需要加强ID MUC的担忧。只需少量增加课程和教员时间就能增强MUC体验。