Reuter Chloe, Chun Nicolette, Pariani Mitchel, Hanson-Kahn Andrea
Stanford Center for Inherited Cardiovascular Disease, Division of Cardiovascular Medicine, Stanford School of Medicine, Stanford, California.
Stanford Center for Undiagnosed Diseases, Division of Cardiovascular Medicine, Stanford School of Medicine, Stanford, California.
J Genet Couns. 2019 Aug;28(4):878-886. doi: 10.1002/jgc4.1130. Epub 2019 May 3.
Variants of uncertain significance (VUSs) are often disclosed to patients despite ambiguous association with disease risk and lack of clinical actionability. It is important to understand how patients understand a VUS result, but few studies have assessed this. Our qualitative study explored patient recall, reaction to, and interpretation of a VUS in the context of multigene panels. We conducted 11 semi-structured phone interviews with adults who had a VUS identified on multigene panel testing in a hereditary oncology clinic, with questions focusing on the VUS result, personal and family history, and motivations for and expectations of genetic testing. Transcripts were coded iteratively, using both deductive and inductive codes. Overall, participants usually recalled that they had a VUS, despite variation in the vocabulary used. Participants responded both emotionally and intellectually to receiving information about having a VUS, which was often a result of their expectations and motivations prior to testing. Overall, participants understood the lack of clinical significance of a VUS, yet often interpreted the etiologic significance of a VUS within the context of the personal and family history. Our study provides insight into a process by which patients translate uncertain genetic testing results into a construct that fits within their current belief framework and which may be facilitated by a genetic counselor.
意义未明的变异(VUS)常常会告知患者,尽管其与疾病风险的关联尚不明确且缺乏临床可操作性。了解患者如何理解VUS结果很重要,但很少有研究对此进行评估。我们的定性研究探讨了在多基因检测背景下患者对VUS的回忆、反应及解读。我们对在一家遗传性肿瘤诊所接受多基因检测时发现VUS的成年人进行了11次半结构化电话访谈,问题聚焦于VUS结果、个人及家族病史,以及基因检测的动机和期望。使用演绎和归纳编码对访谈记录进行迭代编码。总体而言,尽管使用的词汇有所不同,但参与者通常记得自己有一个VUS。参与者在收到有关VUS的信息时,在情感和理智上都有反应,这往往是他们检测前的期望和动机所致。总体而言,参与者理解VUS缺乏临床意义,但往往会在个人和家族病史的背景下解读VUS的病因学意义。我们的研究深入了解了患者将不确定的基因检测结果转化为符合其当前信念框架的概念的过程,而这一过程可能会得到遗传咨询师的帮助。