Ganga River Ecology Research Laboratory, Environmental Science Division, Centre of Advanced Study in Botany, Institute of Science, Banaras Hindu University, Varanasi, 221005, India.
Department of Botany, Faculty of Science and Technology, Mahatma Gandhi Kashi Vidyapith, Varanasi, 221002, India.
Arch Environ Contam Toxicol. 2019 Aug;77(2):263-278. doi: 10.1007/s00244-019-00638-5. Epub 2019 May 25.
We investigated the distribution of Zn, Cu, Ni, Pb, Cr, and Cd in water, sediment, and two dietary fish (an omnivore, Labeo rohita and a benthic carnivore, Clarias batrachus) and potential health risk to human consumers during summer low flow (2017-2018) at 28 sites across 7 tributary confluences of the Ganga River. We selected Devprayag, an upper reach site, as a reference for data comparison. We found significant spatial variations in the distribution of study metals and the concentrations remained higher in tributaries, confluences, and downstream cities. The pollution load index showed all sites except Devprayag in the polluted category. Ecological risk analysis indicated 1 site with very high risk, 7 with considerable risk, and 10 with moderate-risk category. The Zn did appear the most, and Cd the least accumulated metal in the fish. The metal accumulation was higher in C. batrachus. The levels of Cd, Cr, and Pb in the study fishes were higher compared with the international standards. The health risk analysis indicated safe levels for individual metals except for Cd where the target hazard quotient (THQ) did exceed 1 for C. batrachus at the Ramganga and Varuna confluences. When all metals were considered, the THQ was > 1 (> 2 for C. batrachus), indicating the full possibility of adverse health effects to human consumers. Our study highlights the importance of tributaries in creating a mosaic of metal-rich habitats in the Ganga River and food chain associated with a health risk to human consumers.
我们调查了锌、铜、镍、铅、铬和镉在夏季低流量(2017-2018 年)期间的水、沉积物和两种食用鱼(杂食性的罗非鱼和底栖肉食性的鲶鱼)中的分布情况,以及对人类消费者的潜在健康风险。在恒河的 7 条支流汇流处的 28 个地点进行了研究。我们选择上游的德夫普拉亚格作为数据比较的参考点。我们发现研究金属的分布存在显著的空间变化,而且浓度在支流、汇流处和下游城市中仍然较高。污染负荷指数显示,除了德夫普拉亚格,所有其他地点都属于污染类别。生态风险分析表明,有 1 个地点存在极高风险,7 个地点存在相当大的风险,10 个地点存在中等风险。锌似乎是鱼类中积累最多的金属,而镉是积累最少的金属。鲶鱼体内的金属积累量更高。研究鱼类中 Cd、Cr 和 Pb 的水平高于国际标准。健康风险分析表明,除了 Cd 之外,个别金属的水平是安全的,在 Ramganga 和 Varuna 汇流处,鲶鱼的目标危害系数(THQ)超过了 1。当考虑所有金属时,THQ 大于 1(对于鲶鱼来说,THQ 大于 2),这表明人类消费者可能会受到不良健康影响。我们的研究强调了支流在恒河形成富含金属的生境马赛克和食物链的重要性,这与人类消费者的健康风险有关。