Jiang F, Zeng Y Q, Qian M, Cai S, Chen Y, Chen P
Department of Respiratory Medicine, the Second Xiangya Hospital of Central South University, Changsha 410000, China.
Zhonghua Yi Xue Za Zhi. 2019 May 14;99(18):1385-1389. doi: 10.3760/cma.j.issn.0376-2491.2019.18.006.
To explore quality of spirometry in Hunan province and the impact of education on it. Cross-sectional study and a prospective randomized cohort study. (1) A total of 460 public hospitals in Hunan province were investigated. Research assistants collected 20 consecutive reports of pulmonary ventilation test reports (PVTRs) and basal information of those hospitals which owned spirometry. (2) To measure the effect of education, 28 randomly selected 2(nd) level hospitals which owned spirometry were randomized to intervention and control group (1∶1). The intervention group received a short-time training which included face-to-face lectures and a hand-by-hand operation training course, while the control group received usual care. PVTRs were investigated 3 months after the intervention. All PVTRs were classified to grade A, B, C, D and E according to the Chinese pulmonary ventilation test (PVT) guidelines. The recovery rate was 100%. The spirometry-equipped ratio was 1.6% (2/129) at 1(st) level hospitals, 39.0% (105/269) at 2(nd) level hospitals, 100% (62/62) at 3(rd) level hospitals in Hunan province. There were 100% (2/2), 91.4% (96/105) and 93.5% (58/62) utilization rate at 1(st), 2(nd) and 3(rd) level hospitals. Common reasons for not owning a spirometer were equipment cost and insufficient insurance. Lack of knowledge about spirometry and inadequate benefits were the top two reasons for low utilization rate. There were 3 120 PVTRs from 156 hospitals which used spirometry, a total of 50.4% (1 574/3 120) PVTRs got grade A, a total of 14.8% (462/3 120) PVTRs were judged as unreliable (grade D, E). There were 560 PVTRs and 28 questionnaires, respectively, before and after intervention. The technicians' knowledge improved after education compared to before (9.8±0.6 vs 8.6±1.1) (0.05). And 75.0% (210/280) PVTRs got A grade in the intervention group, which was significantly higher than those in the control group (75.0% vs 37.9%, 0.05). While none of PVTRs was unreliable, which was lower than that in the control group (0 vs 14.6%, 0.05). The equipment ratio and the utilization rate of spirometry are still low and imbalanced among three levels hospitals in Hunan. The short-time training is helpful to improve quality of spirometry.
探讨湖南省肺功能检查的质量以及教育对其的影响。采用横断面研究和前瞻性随机队列研究。(1)对湖南省460家公立医院进行调查。研究助手收集了拥有肺功能仪的医院连续20份肺通气功能测试报告(PVTRs)及基础信息。(2)为衡量教育的效果,随机选取28家拥有肺功能仪的二级医院,按1∶1随机分为干预组和对照组。干预组接受包括面对面授课和手把手操作培训课程的短期培训,而对照组接受常规护理。干预3个月后对PVTRs进行调查。所有PVTRs根据中国肺通气功能测试(PVT)指南分为A、B、C、D和E级。回收率为100%。湖南省一级医院肺功能仪配备率为1.6%(2/129),二级医院为39.0%(105/269),三级医院为100%(62/62)。一级、二级和三级医院的使用率分别为100%(2/2)、91.4%(96/105)和93.5%(58/62)。未拥有肺功能仪的常见原因是设备成本和保险不足。对肺功能检查知识缺乏了解和效益不足是使用率低的前两大原因。来自156家使用肺功能仪医院的PVTRs有3120份,共有50.4%(1574/3120)的PVTRs评为A级,共有14.8%(462/3120)的PVTRs被判定为不可靠(D级、E级)。干预前后分别有560份PVTRs和28份问卷。与教育前相比,教育后技术人员的知识有所提高(9.8±0.6对8.6±1.1)(P<0.05)。干预组75.0%(210/280)的PVTRs评为A级,显著高于对照组(75.0%对37.9%,P<0.05)。而干预组无PVTRs不可靠,低于对照组(0对14.6%,P<0.05)。湖南省三级医院肺功能仪的配备率和使用率仍较低且不均衡。短期培训有助于提高肺功能检查质量。