Rebecca J. Gorges is a PhD candidate in the Harris School of Public Policy, University of Chicago, in Illinois.
Prachi Sanghavi is an assistant professor in the Department of Public Health Sciences, University of Chicago.
Health Aff (Millwood). 2019 Jul;38(7):1110-1118. doi: 10.1377/hlthaff.2018.05409.
The benefits of expanding funding for Medicaid long-term care home and community-based services (HCBS) relative to institutional care are often taken as self-evident. However, little is known about the outcomes of these services, especially for racial and ethnic minority groups, whose members tend to use the services more than whites do, and for people with dementia who may need high-intensity care. Using national Medicaid claims data on older adults enrolled in both Medicare and Medicaid, we found that overall hospitalization rates were similar for HCBS and nursing facility users, although nursing facility users were generally sicker as reflected in their claims history. Among HCBS users, blacks were more likely to be hospitalized than non-Hispanic whites were, and the gap widened among blacks and whites with dementia. Also, conditional on receiving HCBS, Medicaid HCBS spending was higher for whites than for nonwhites, and higher Medicare and Medicaid hospital spending for blacks and Hispanics did not offset this difference. Our findings suggest that home and community-based services need to be carefully targeted to avoid adverse outcomes and that the racial/ethnic disparities in access to high-quality institutional long-term care are also present in HCBS. Policy makers should consider the full costs and benefits of shifting care from nursing facilities to home and community settings and the potential implications for equity.
扩大医疗补助长期护理家庭和社区服务(HCBS)资金的好处通常被认为是不言而喻的。然而,对于这些服务的结果却知之甚少,尤其是对于少数民族群体,他们的成员比白人更倾向于使用这些服务,而且对于可能需要高强度护理的痴呆症患者也是如此。我们使用了全国医疗补助计划(Medicaid)关于同时参加医疗保险(Medicare)和医疗补助计划的老年人的数据,发现 HCBS 和疗养院使用者的总体住院率相似,尽管疗养院使用者的病情通常更严重,这反映在他们的索赔记录中。在 HCBS 用户中,黑人住院的可能性高于非西班牙裔白人,而痴呆症患者的差距则进一步扩大。此外,在接受 HCBS 的前提下,白人的医疗补助 HCBS 支出高于非白人,而黑人(Black)和西班牙裔(Hispanic)的医疗保险和医疗补助计划的住院支出并不能抵消这一差异。我们的研究结果表明,家庭和社区服务需要有针对性地提供,以避免不良后果,而且在获得高质量机构长期护理方面的种族/族裔差异也存在于 HCBS 中。政策制定者应该考虑从疗养院转移护理的全部成本和收益,以及这对公平性可能产生的影响。