Hua Andrew, Quicksall Zachary, Di Chongzhi, Motl Robert, LaCroix Andrea Z, Schatz Bruce, Buchner David M
1University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, Urbana, IL USA.
2Carl R. Woese Institute for Genomic Biology, Urbana, IL USA.
NPJ Digit Med. 2018 Jul 11;1:25. doi: 10.1038/s41746-018-0033-5. eCollection 2018.
Current clinical methods of screening older adults for fall risk have difficulties. We analyzed data on 67 women (mean age = 77.5 years) who participated in the Objective Physical Activity and Cardiovascular Health (OPACH) study within the Women's Health Initiative and in an accelerometer calibration substudy. Participants completed the short physical performance battery (SPPB), questions about falls in the past year, and a timed 400-m walk while wearing a hip triaxial accelerometer (30 Hz). Women with SPPB ≤ 9 and 1+reported falls ( = 19) were grouped as high fall risk; women with SPPB = 10-12 and 0 reported falls ( = 48) were grouped as low fall risk. Random Forests were trained to classify women into these groups, based upon traditional measures of gait and/or signal-based features extracted from accelerometer data. Eleven models investigated combined feature effects on classification accuracy, using 10-fold cross-validation. The models had an average 73.7% accuracy, 81.1% precision, and 0.706 AUC. The best performing model including triaxial data, cross-correlations, and traditional measures of gait had 78.9% accuracy, 84.4% precision, and 0.846 AUC. Mediolateral signal-based measures-coefficient of variance, cross-correlation with anteroposterior accelerations, and mean acceleration-ranked as the top 3 features. The classification accuracy is promising, given research on probabilistic models of falls indicates accuracies ≥80% are challenging to achieve. The results suggest accelerometer-based measures captured during walking are potentially useful in screening older women for fall risk. We are applying algorithms developed in this paper on an OPACH dataset of 5000 women with a 1-year prospective falls log and week-long, free-living accelerometer data.
目前用于筛查老年人跌倒风险的临床方法存在困难。我们分析了67名女性(平均年龄 = 77.5岁)的数据,她们参与了女性健康倡议中的客观身体活动与心血管健康(OPACH)研究以及一项加速度计校准子研究。参与者完成了简短体能测试电池(SPPB)、关于过去一年跌倒情况的问题,并在佩戴髋部三轴加速度计(30 Hz)的情况下进行了400米定时步行。SPPB评分≤9且报告有1次及以上跌倒的女性(n = 19)被归为高跌倒风险组;SPPB评分为10 - 12且报告无跌倒的女性(n = 48)被归为低跌倒风险组。基于从加速度计数据中提取的传统步态测量和/或基于信号的特征,训练随机森林模型将女性分为这两组。使用10折交叉验证,11个模型研究了组合特征对分类准确性的影响。这些模型的平均准确率为73.7%、精确率为81.1%、曲线下面积(AUC)为0.706。表现最佳的模型包括三轴数据、互相关以及传统步态测量,其准确率为78.9%、精确率为84.4%、AUC为0.846。基于信号的内外侧测量——变异系数、与前后向加速度的互相关以及平均加速度——位列前三大特征。考虑到关于跌倒概率模型的研究表明,要达到≥80%的准确率具有挑战性,因此该分类准确率很有前景。结果表明,步行过程中采集的基于加速度计的测量指标在筛查老年女性跌倒风险方面可能有用。我们正在将本文开发的算法应用于一个包含5000名女性的OPACH数据集,该数据集有1年的前瞻性跌倒记录以及为期一周的自由生活加速度计数据。