Bakar Nurul Salwana Abu, Manual Adilius, Hamid Jabrullah Ab
Institute for Health Systems Research, Ministry of Health Malaysia, Shah Alam, Selangor, Malaysia.
Malays J Med Sci. 2019 Jul;26(4):79-85. doi: 10.21315/mjms2019.26.4.9. Epub 2019 Aug 29.
Equity is one of the important aspects of universal health coverage. Variation in socioeconomic status (SES) has been proved to contribute discrepancies in the use of healthcare services. This study aimed to assess equity for inpatient, outpatient and dental care utilisation by household SES over time.
This study used five series of National Health and Morbidity Survey data from 1986 to 2015. Healthcare utilisation for inpatient, outpatient and dental care were analysed. SES was grouped based on household expenditure variables accounting for total number of adults and children in the household using consumption per adult equivalents approach. The determination of healthcare utilisation across the SES segments was measured using concentration index.
The overall distribution of inpatient utilisation tended towards the pro-poor, although only data from 1996 (-value = 0.017) and 2006 (-value = 0.021) were statistically significant ( < 0.05). Out-patient care showed changing trends from initially being pro-rich in 1986 ( < 0.05), then gradually switching to pro-poor in 2015 ( < 0.05). Dental care utilisation was significantly pro-rich throughout the survey period ( < 0.05). Public providers mostly showed significantly pro-poor trends for both in- and out-patient care ( < 0.05). Private providers, meanwhile, constantly showed a significantly pro-rich ( < 0.05) trend of utilisation.
Total health utilisation was close to being equal across SES throughout the years. However, this overall effect exhibited inequities as the effect of pro-rich utilisation in the private sector negated the pro-poor utilisation in the public sector. Strategies to improve equity should be consistent by increasing accessibility to the private sectors, which has been primarily dominated by the richest population.
公平是全民健康覆盖的重要方面之一。社会经济地位(SES)的差异已被证明会导致医疗服务使用上的差异。本研究旨在评估家庭社会经济地位随时间变化对住院、门诊和牙科护理利用的公平性。
本研究使用了1986年至2015年的五组全国健康与发病率调查数据。分析了住院、门诊和牙科护理的医疗服务利用情况。社会经济地位根据家庭支出变量进行分组,采用成人当量消费法计算家庭中成人和儿童的总数。使用集中指数衡量社会经济地位各阶层之间的医疗服务利用情况。
住院服务利用的总体分布倾向于有利于穷人,尽管只有1996年(-值 = 0.017)和2006年(-值 = 0.021)的数据具有统计学意义(< 0.05)。门诊护理呈现出变化趋势,最初在1986年有利于富人(< 0.05),然后在2015年逐渐转向有利于穷人(< 0.05)。在整个调查期间,牙科护理利用明显有利于富人(< 0.05)。公共提供者在住院和门诊护理方面大多呈现出明显有利于穷人的趋势(< 0.05)。与此同时,私人提供者持续呈现出明显有利于富人(< 0.05)的利用趋势。
多年来,总体医疗利用在社会经济地位之间接近平等。然而,这种总体效果存在不公平现象,因为私营部门有利于富人的利用效应抵消了公共部门有利于穷人的利用效应。改善公平性的策略应保持一致,增加私营部门的可及性,私营部门主要由最富有的人群主导。