Independent Research Scientist, Nairobi, Kenya
Kenya Hospices and Palliative Care Association (KEHPCA), Nairobi, Kenya.
Oncologist. 2019 Dec;24(12):1549-1556. doi: 10.1634/theoncologist.2019-0257. Epub 2019 Oct 10.
Early detection and prompt access to quality treatment and palliative care are critical for good breast cancer outcomes. Interventions require understanding of identified barriers and facilitators to care. A hermeneutic phenomenological approach, whose purpose is to describe feelings and lived experiences of participants, can expand the existing scope of understanding of barriers and facilitators in accessing breast cancer care in Kenya.
This is qualitative research applying focus groups and a hermeneutic phenomenological approach to identify barriers and facilitators to breast cancer care from the knowledge, perceptions, and lived experiences of women with and without a diagnosis of breast cancer in Kenya. We conducted four focus group discussions with 6-11 women aged 30-60 years in each. Groups were classified according to breast cancer diagnosis and socioeconomic status. The transcribed discussions were coded independently by two investigators. Together they reviewed the codes and identified themes.
The key barriers were costs, inadequate knowledge, distance to health facilities, communication with health providers, medicines stockouts, long waiting periods, limited or no counseling at diagnosis, patient vulnerability, and limited access to rehabilitation items. Facilitators were dependable social support, periodical access to subsidized awareness, and early detection services and friendly caregivers. We found no marked differences in perceptions between groups by socioeconomic status.
There is need for targeted awareness and education for health providers and the public, early detection services with onsite counseling and cost mitigation. Support from the society and religious organizations and persons may be leveraged as adjuncts to conventional management. Further interpretations are encouraged.
Continuing cancer education for health providers in technical skills for early detection, treatment, and survivorship care, as well as nontechnical skills like communication, and an understanding of their patients' preferences and socioeconomic status may guide individualized management plans and positively affect patient experiences. Patients and the general public also need education on cancer to avoid misconceptions and inaccuracies that perpetuate fear, confusion, delayed presentation for treatment, and stigma. Critical analysis of the cancer care value chain and processes, development, and implementation of interventions to reduce costs while streamlining processes may improve client experiences.
早期发现和及时获得高质量的治疗和姑息治疗对乳腺癌的良好结果至关重要。干预措施需要了解确定的护理障碍和促进因素。解释学现象学方法的目的是描述参与者的感受和生活经历,可以扩展对肯尼亚乳腺癌护理中障碍和促进因素的现有理解范围。
这是一项定性研究,采用焦点小组和解释学现象学方法,从肯尼亚有和没有乳腺癌诊断的妇女的知识、看法和生活经历中,确定乳腺癌护理的障碍和促进因素。我们在肯尼亚进行了四项焦点小组讨论,每组有 6-11 名年龄在 30-60 岁的妇女参加。小组根据乳腺癌诊断和社会经济地位进行分类。两名研究人员独立对转录的讨论进行编码。他们一起审查了这些代码并确定了主题。
主要障碍是费用、知识不足、与卫生设施的距离、与卫生提供者的沟通、药品缺货、长时间等待、诊断时有限或没有咨询、患者脆弱性以及康复用品有限。促进因素是可靠的社会支持、定期获得补贴的意识和早期检测服务以及友好的护理人员。我们没有发现社会经济地位不同的群体之间对这些问题的看法有明显差异。
需要针对卫生保健提供者和公众进行有针对性的意识和教育,提供早期检测服务,包括现场咨询和成本缓解。可以利用社会和宗教组织以及个人的支持作为常规管理的辅助手段。鼓励进一步的解释。
继续对卫生保健提供者进行癌症教育,包括早期发现、治疗和生存护理方面的技术技能,以及沟通等非技术技能,并了解他们患者的偏好和社会经济地位,这可能会指导个体化管理计划,并对患者体验产生积极影响。患者和公众也需要接受癌症教育,以避免误解和不准确信息,这些误解和不准确信息会导致恐惧、困惑、延迟治疗和污名化。对癌症护理价值链和流程进行批判性分析,制定和实施降低成本同时简化流程的干预措施,可能会改善客户体验。