Sors Fabrizio, Tomé Lourido David, Parisi Vittoria, Santoro Ilaria, Galmonte Alessandra, Agostini Tiziano, Murgia Mauro
Department of Medicine, Surgery and Health Sciences, University of Trieste, Trieste, Italy.
Department of Life Sciences, University of Trieste, Trieste, Italy.
Front Psychol. 2019 Oct 21;10:2380. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2019.02380. eCollection 2019.
The decision-making processes of referees in sports are affected by many factors, including the pressure of spectators. While the home/visitor bias has been previously investigated, the role of crowd noise has been less studied. In the present study, we investigated how the crowd noise (calm vs. pressing) influence the decisions of basketball referees, when examining videos of potential fouls. In doing so, we also considered the level of competitive anxiety of referees (low vs. high anxiety), as factor potentially interacting with the pressure exerted by the spectators. A 2 × 2 ANOVA (Crowd noise x Anxiety) revealed a significant interaction [ = 7.33; < 0.05; = 0.21; power = 0.74], with the highly anxious referees showing poorer performances in the pressing crowd condition [ = 2.24; < 0.05; = 0.64]. The results indicate that the crowd noise does not seem to affect the referees' decisions, unless we consider the anxiety. The present findings suggest that the decisions of referees with high anxiety might be more easily influenced by external factors like crowd noise. Based on these results, referees' federations should consider the possibility to develop training protocols dedicated to highly anxious referees, to avoid their decisions from being biased by spectators' pressure.
体育比赛中裁判的决策过程受到多种因素影响,包括观众的压力。虽然主场/客场偏见此前已被研究,但人群噪音的作用却较少被探讨。在本研究中,我们调查了在查看潜在犯规视频时,人群噪音(安静与嘈杂)如何影响篮球裁判的决策。在此过程中,我们还考虑了裁判的竞争焦虑水平(低焦虑与高焦虑),这是一个可能与观众施加的压力相互作用的因素。一项2×2方差分析(人群噪音×焦虑)显示出显著的交互作用[F = 7.33;p < 0.05;η² = 0.21;检验效能 = 0.74],高焦虑裁判在嘈杂人群环境中的表现较差[F = 2.24;p < 0.05;η² = 0.64]。结果表明,人群噪音似乎并不影响裁判的决策,除非考虑焦虑因素。目前的研究结果表明,高焦虑裁判的决策可能更容易受到人群噪音等外部因素的影响。基于这些结果,裁判协会应考虑制定专门针对高焦虑裁判的培训方案,以避免他们的决策受到观众压力的影响而产生偏差。